High school committee approves contract for renewable energy credits

High school committee approves contract for renewable energy credits

by -

The Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School (MVRHS) school committee voted Tuesday to approve a 20-year contract to buy renewable energy credits (RECs) from Future Generation Wind (FGW) to reduce the school’s future electricity costs.

The net metering credits are associated with a wind turbine project FGW plans to construct on a cranberry farm owned by Keith Mann in Plymouth off Route 25. The project has already received state, federal, and local permits.

The school committee’s vote followed a brief presentation by Todd Bard, president of LEE Energy Group, whose company is paid by the developer to sell the RECs. The committee had agreed at its January meeting to put Mr. Bard on the February agenda, at the suggestion of school business administrator Amy Tierney, who was contacted on the school district’s behalf by him. In the interim, about six weeks ago, Ms. Tierney emailed the committee members a copy of the proposed contract to review.

At Monday’s meeting, Mr. Bard explained that renewable energy projects receive net metering credits for electricity produced that goes into the “grid.” By purchasing the RECs, the high school would receive credit on its electric bills, at a minimum savings of 20 percent and an estimated $3 million over the life of the contract.

Mr. Bard said the RECs are being sold to both public purchasers, such as the high school and other municipal entities, and private purchasers. Cronig’s Market has signed on as a private purchaser, he said, and he has had initial discussions with Martha’s Vineyard Hospital as another possible private purchaser. The Dukes County commissioners voted January 8 to approve a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Future Generation Wind, but have not signed a contract.

The project will include four turbines, three on one side of the highway, and one on the other, constructed in bogs that are about 1,500 feet away from the nearest residents, Mr. Bard said.

“And the cranberries won’t complain,” Ms. Tierney added with a smile.

Mr. Bard said FGW hopes to start construction by the end of the year. Committee member Dan Cabot of West Tisbury asked him what would happen if the state changed its legislation and NSTAR was no longer required to buy energy produced by the wind turbines.

“NSTAR doesn’t buy the power, the ratepayers do,” Mr. Bard said, adding that he thought it highly unlikely the law would be changed.

Committee member Robert Lionette of Chilmark asked if the FGW project is a one-shot deal for the high school. Mr. Bard said it would be possible for the school district to take on another solar energy project down the road.

Mr. Bard noted that the developer has agreed to share his profits 50/50, which he said is unusual. “And if the discount rates fall below 20 percent, before the developer starts to recoup his money, you’ll get the lost savings returned to you,” he said.

In a phone call Wednesday, Ms. Tierney explained that the high school district would have a “tracking account,” to ensure it receives its minimum 20 percent savings.

“And if we don’t, the difference in what we didn’t get back in any given year would be provided to us in a future year,” she said. “Currently, the developers are projecting upwards of 27 percent.”

Ms. Tierney said she anticipates it will cost the school district between $2,000 to $3,000 to have the contract documents reviewed by legal counsel. Otherwise, there is no other cost involved with the project.

Ms. Tierney said the contract also includes a provision for discounted electricity for a new superintendent’s office building, now in the planning stages, that may be constructed later on the high school grounds.

In other business, the school committee voted to recertify the high school’s fiscal year 2015 budget, to reflect a decrease of $104,000 in health insurance costs. Ms. Tierney said the Cape Cod Municipal Health Group recently set health insurance rates for next year at an increase of 1.8 percent, rather than the eight percent anticipated and budgeted.

With the reduction in health insurance costs, Ms. Tierney said the high school’s FY15 total operating and capital budget is $18,546,250. She also recalculated the Island towns’ assessments at $15,269,407, an increase of 5.24 percent over last year, based on numbers for required minimum local contributions she received from the state in January.


The school committee also voted not to sign an MOU with the Up-Island Regional School District (UIRSD) for bus transportation. The MOU, initially proposed by UIRSD school committee chairman Jeffrey “Skipper” Manter, states that the district would not be held responsible for the cost of insurance deductibles in the event students from Edgartown, Tisbury, and West Tisbury were injured in an accident while riding on a UIRSD-owned bus. The cost would be passed on to their towns of residence.

“My concern is it could be another $5,000 we haven’t budgeted for,” committee member Priscilla Sylvia of Oak Bluffs said. “If the Up-Island Regional School District is really concerned about the $5,000 they’re going to lose, they’re the ones that should assume a gap insurance policy to cover it rather than throwing it on someone who hasn’t anticipated it.”

UIRSD committee members Dan Cabot and Robert Lionette voted against Ms. Sylvia’s motion to reject the MOU.

In other discussion, MVRHS accounts manager Mark Friedman noted that the high school took in more than $12,000 in ticket sales last weekend for the musical “Cats,” the highest total of receipts and attendance for any high school production to date. Several school committee members praised the students in the cast for their impressive performances. Principal Stephen Nixon also gave kudos to the music and theater departments for scrambling to schedule an additional matinee on Monday afternoon, and getting the word out, when Saturday night’s performance was canceled due to a snowstorm.

This month’s student spotlight featured senior Jackie Menton, who talked about her volunteer work with special education students, hospital patients, and Camp Jabberwocky, as well as her involvement in several community organizations.


  1. Yes this Plymouth project is just another disaster in the making 4 2MW turbines with about 300 homes within 2,000 feet.

  2. RE: High School Commiittee approves:

    (The project will include four turbines, three on one side of the highway, and one on the other, constructed in bogs that are about 1,500 feet away from the nearest residents, Mr. Bard said.

    “And the cranberries won’t complain,” Ms. Tierney added with a smile.)

    Ms. Tierney, the cranberries won’t complain, BUT for certain the residents in the 300 residences within about 2000 feet of the turbines will not be smiling….do your homework.

    A good place to start, check out DPU 13 – 165 online; some very interesting comments there about siting industrial wind turbines too close to people’s homes, your “neighbors” homes.


  3. Public Health Protection: Where Do You Draw the Line?

    The justification between differences of multi-jurisdictional public health protection has become clouded. All indications point to “Blood money.”

    Pilgrim Nuclear Station

    On the heels of Fukushima, Plymouth’s Pilgrim Plant operation has been the concern of considerable public opposition. In 2013, every Cape town, through Town Meeting or ballot vote, approved petitions asking Gov. Patrick, as the state’s top official, to call for Pilgrim’s closure. The public’s health on Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket was then, and remains threatened by the operation at Pilgrim

    Future Generation Wind (FGW)

    *Four industrial sized wind turbines co-located on an Ocean Spray cranberry farm in Plymouth, MA as near as 1000 feet from residential property owners.

    On the heels of the states continuing examination of public safety and land-based industrial wind turbine siting
    (see Oct 31, 2013 investigation by the state’s Department of Public Utilities for the Siting of Land-Based Wind Energy Facilities and the MassDEP Wind Turbine and Noise Technical Advisory Group (WNTAG) who’s mission is to advise; protect public health, safety and well-being relative land-based industrial wind energy projects)
    FGW recently won approval from the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School (MVRHS) school committee and the Duxbury Board of Selectmen to contract the sale of renewable energy credits (RECs) to reduce future school and municipal electricity costs.

    Demarcation Denominator

    Public health concerns extending beyond the town-lines of Plymouth, regarding Pilgrim, are arguably warranted. Giving concern to whether the same town-line should veil and separate concern for a neighboring municipality’s residents, if the state’s investigations are indicative of “unknown safe zones,” from a similar, yet demensionally smaller, public health concern?

    Is it fundamentally permissible as a coalition of communities, to contract fiscal reparations for one community while potentially threatening the health and well being of residents in another?

    When does a town’s boundary, in this – the greatest country on earth – define concern and caring for your neighbor in the next town over? The distinction whether to care or not is seeminly becoming tied to money, more often than not.

    Happy Lenten Season to all