Martha’s Vineyard rental scams crop up with approach of summer

Martha’s Vineyard rental scams crop up with approach of summer

by -

Seasonal employees seeking housing have lost money to phony online listings.

Take care when attempting to rent houses.

Martha’s Vineyard is a popular destination for vacationers and college students seeking summer employment. The Island’s popularity and the convenience of web rentals provide fertile ground for scam artists who create fake rental websites.

Realtor Leslie Floyd of Portfolio Real Estate MV in Edgartown emailed The Times Monday to report that she had received two calls the previous weekend from people who were duped by ads on

On Saturday, a young man called Ms. Floyd to ask if her agency represented an address in Katama. With a summer job lined up on the Vineyard, he said he found the house listed on Craigslist, and made arrangements to rent it for the summer. He had already wired money via Western Union for the deposit. He said the owner, whose name he knew, was supposed to meet him there with a key.

“Of course, the ‘landlord’ was nowhere to be found,” Ms. Floyd said in her email. “The owner of the home had no idea what was transpiring.”

In a follow-up phone conversation with The Times, Ms. Floyd said she had to break the news to the man that her agency had already rented the house to an Edgartown business for summer employees. And, that once he wired the money, it was gone.

Upset by his experience, Ms. Floyd posted a message under the heading of “Public Service” on Portfolio Real Estate’s Facebook page.

“If you are looking to rent a home on Martha’s Vineyard either for the season or a vacation rental for a week or two, please be very careful who you rent from and how the monies are transferred,” Ms. Floyd warned. “A reputable landlord or Real Estate rental agency would never ask you to send money via Western Union.”

Warning pays off

Fortunately, Ms. Floyd’s message caught the attention of a young woman from Croatia seeking rental housing for 14 women who plan to work on Martha’s Vineyard this summer. The young woman was about to transfer money from her bank in response to a rental offer she found on Craigslist, when she happened to see a warning Ms. Floyd posted on her Facebook page. She emailed Ms. Floyd to ask if the rental was legit.

“It absolutely was not,” Ms. Floyd said.

Ms. Floyd emailed the contact in the dubious listing and received a suspicious reply.

“Not only did it contain improper English and odd phrasing, it also had made vague references to ‘guarantees,’” Ms. Floyd said. “The email asked for funds to be transferred to a bank at an address in South Carolina, and gave a specific routing number. When I looked it up online, the number turned out to belong to bank in Virginia.”

After warning the young woman about the first scam, Ms. Floyd said she received a follow-up email from her about a second suspicious listing on Craigslist. By the time Ms. Floyd did a search for it, however, it had been removed.

“I have email trails for the three listings I found out about, and contacted the real owners,” Ms. Floyd said.

She found two of the properties were also listed on and, which she said have since been removed.

Ms. Floyd said she has already notified the Federal Trade Commission and planned to notify the State Attorney General’s office on Tuesday, since it was closed Monday for Patriot’s Day.

“I know you can’t always catch everybody, but I feel it’s really important, with so many people in our seasonal workforce coming from so far away, and housing being so tight here, that they don’t take these last-ditch, phony offers out of desperation,” Ms. Floyd said. “A lot of them have lined up jobs and paid their airfare, and have taken their savings out to do it.”

Scam prevention

Would-be renters who are told they must wire money or arrange for bank fund transfers, or that they can’t see the inside of a house before renting it, should view those stipulations as a red flag, Ms. Floyd said.

“You always want to rent from a reputable agent,” she said. “At the very least, you should check on who actually owns the home through Vision Appraisal or Massachusetts land records.”

Unfortunately, seasonal and vacation rental scams are nothing new. Ms. Floyd said that although her recent experience was a first for her agency, she knows other Island real estate agents who have dealt with such scams and continue to warn their clients about them.

Two years agoThe Times reported that an Edgartown couple had been contacted by two different people who said they paid an online advertiser thousands of dollars to rent their house. The couple knew nothing about it.

A rental scam like the one they experienced follows a typical pattern. It begins with an online advertisement that seems like a great bargain, progresses with contact by email or phone from someone far away, and ends with a request to wire money to a third person or location. Consumer advocates, and even Craigslist itself, warn consumers about all three elements of the scam.

“Deal locally with folks you can meet in person,” the Craigslist website advises under the heading, “Avoiding Scams.”

“Never wire funds via Western Union, Moneygram, or any other wire service,” the site says. “Anyone who asks you to do so is likely a scammer.”

In concert with Ms. Floyd’s advice, Craigslist also reminds consumers, “Do not rent housing or purchase goods sight unseen — that amazing rental or cheap item may not exist.”


  1. I’m glad people are being warned about this but I also think it’s common sense. Why would anyone wire money to someone they’ve never met to rent a house they’ve never seen? Come on people. I’ve come across several of these craigslist posts over the years during my housing search. It’s very obvious that something isn’t right. Broken/strange English, other countries, needing the money ASAP, and most of all no option to see the house. The bottom line is if it sounds way too good to be true, it probably is.

    1. There’s the matter of competition. If one waits an extra day, the house may get rented to another.

      1. Also, many people who are attempting to rent are from far away places and may be renting for the first time. They may have no idea what the market is here or what are the safe rental precautions. Thanks to Leslie Floyd and the MV Times for making the renting public aware of these scams.

      2. I agree, but I think common sense should set in BEFORE it gets to the point of wiring money to someone in a foreign country.

  2. In an update, Leslie Floyd told The Times that a caller saw a Slough Cove Road listing for $980/month that had a California phone exchange of 909. A check of the phone number revealed it is a reroute from West Bengal.

    1. Don’t let the readers get fooled by a 508, 617, or 774 exchange either. If a scammer buys a throw-away cell phone they can pick any exchange they want.

      1. Don’t even need a cell phone you can do it with any number of online phone services like Skype, NetTalk, Google Voice, VOIP providers, etc.

  3. In reference to the
    Times article concerning scams on Craig’s List I have to wonder if
    a bit of healthy competition is getting under the skin of The Times.
    I have sold, rented and purchased on Craigs List and find it works
    great. I have no trouble filling my rentals and though I get my share
    of scamming by those who try to take my money a little common sense
    can go a long way in getting through these scams and in many cases
    you can actually cost the crook a few bucks in the meantime. I post
    often on Craig’s and have my souvenirs from those crooks who have
    tried to scam me in the past. Anyone, today , who would send a
    Western Union payment to another person without knowing who the
    receiver is, has to be living in La La land and still believing in
    the tooth fairy. I find it interesting that The Times has posted this
    article the last couple years at about this time and I have to guess
    it is a scare tactic to try and stop potential renters from using
    Craigs free service and in hopes of driving landlords back to a paid
    advertising format. Craig’s works and it works well, all that is
    needed is a little common sense before you part with your cash. Both
    my rentals have been filled through Craig’s List for several years
    and rented to those who understand the procedure. In the end there
    are a few good free sites where you can find rentals and rentals can
    be posted, just be safe and you might find exactly what you are
    looking to rent.

    1. You really think this is a ploy by the Times to get advertising? Talk about believing in the tooth fairy….

  4. According to, a general MBA can be obtained for as little as $6k and as high as $120k. If students would do a little research, they would find that it is not nearly as expensive to get a college degree