455 State Road
Humphrey’s has grown from humble beginnings peddling turnovers to workmen at the Dukes County Garage in the 1930s, to an Island staple with three locations – Tisbury, Edgartown and Oak Bluffs. They’ve consistently been voted Best of the Vineyard (consecutively since 1999!) for their baked goods, simple yet delicious sandwich offerings and welcoming, comfortable atmosphere. We love to snag a table in the window of the Tisbury shop, tucked back off State Road in the Woodland Center, with coffee and a book and a famous Turkey Gobbler – Oven roasted turkey, homemade stuffing and cranberry sauce heaped between two slices of freshly baked sourdough bread – Humphrey’s own!