23 Kelley St.
This famous Colonial pub can be found at the base of The Kelley House in the heart of the village of Edgartown. Built in 1742, The Kelley House is one of the oldest buildings on Martha’s Vineyard. This rich history and genuine Colonial character is most evident at The Newes From America Pub with its original rough-hewn beams, ballast brick walls and warm hearth.
The menu is a unique blend of American and British pub food, and the bar prides itself on offering some of the most highly rated, limited-release, New England draft beers. A Rack of Beers is available for sampling, and in return get rewarded with wooden nickels. Collect hundreds of them for your own seat at the bar.
The Newes is open year-round for lunch and dinner daily, and does not take reservations.
We like: Roquefort Stilettos, Kelly’s French Dip, and Bangers & Mash.