|
Gone
Fishin'
Catch and release contest attracted fishermen, not fish
June 9, 2005
By
Nelson Sigelman

A fishing boat returns to Menemsha. Photo by Tim Johnson

Delighted Times fishing columnist and news editor Nelson
Sigelman wears a T-shirt he received in the mail yesterday
from an unidentified benefactor. The envelope had a postmark
of Wayne, NJ.
|
My fishing effort
in the 14th Annual Marthas Vineyard Rod and Gun Club Catch and
Release Tournament began with homemade sausage and barbecued ribs.
I wanted to win, but I wanted to eat well even more.
Ned Casey was my fishing team member for the Saturday competition.
He is an excellent cook, a skill that I have come to appreciate over
years of fishing competition.
The tournament is an annual one-night competition that begins at 7
pm and ends at 2 am. Teams of varying size attempt to catch and release
the most striped bass.
Generally speaking, if I do not have fish busting in front of me by
11 pm, I am ready to go home and go to sleep. Ned and I managed to
hang in until a little after 1 am, when we finally decided to call
it quits.
In all, 204 fishermen registered for the tournament, and 194 showed
up to fish Saturday night. Theoretically the conditions for fly-fishing
were perfect: a southwest wind and a dark, moonless night, with a
falling tide at Lobsterville.
There should have been plenty of fish caught, but at the Sunday morning
breakfast that preceded the awards ceremony most of the fishermen
reported little success.
In total, participants caught and released approximately 546 fish,
or three fish per fisherman on average. Of course, there was no average
catch. Some guys caught nothing despite a night-long effort.
For team overweight (believe me there was a lot of poundage), East
Beach, a black fly and an intermediate line proved to be a winning
combination. Lobsterville Beach, usually a consistent winner, proved
to be something of a bust.
I expect that will change very soon, if it has not already. Ned and
I poked around in Sengekontacket and Edgartown and managed to catch
six fish and lose several more. Up-Island team Caddyshack kept up
its winning streak in the one-fly category (meaning each fisherman
can use only one fly for the night) and found lots of fish.
At the awards ceremony Sunday, Charlie Finnerty asked me to announce
that his team member, Mac Haskell, had lost his fly rod and reel in
the trees, an unusual place to lose a fishing rod. He explained that
driving down a dirt road Macs fly snagged on a low tree limb.
Once the entire line unspooled from the reel the entire outfit was
pulled out of the rod holder.
Curious, I asked Charlie, And you didnt hear anything?
We were listening to some tunes, Charlie explained. Its
tough when you lose your one fly, but its tougher when you lose
your whole rod.
Luckily, that same morning at the awards ceremony, Mac recovered his
rod. Before an osprey could incorporate Macs fly rod into a
nest, fisherman Julian Pepper spotted it in the tree limbs.
Not so lucky, Dave Loren put his TNT rod with an Abel reel on top
of his car in Menemsha then drove off. He would be very happy to get
it back and may be reached at 401-247-2738.
The tournament results follow:
Sonny and Joey Beaulieu award for the largest fish caught and released:
Rick Harvey, 54 inches (length and girth); Matthew Whritenour, 51
inches; John Grandin, 50.5 inches.
Arnold Spofford award for most fish caught and released with one fly
by a team: Caddyshack (Mac Haskell, Charlie Finnerty, J.C. Giordano),
9.66 fish average; Scare and Release (Ed and Jim Lepore), 3; Good
Eats (Ned Casey, Nelson Sigelman) 3; We Dont Want No Blues (Dave
Nuttall, Dave Souza, Brent Baer), 2.66.
Roberto Germani award for the most fish caught and released by a team:
Sandra Demel, John Kollett, 10.5 fish average; Team Overweight (Nick
Fersen, Paul Fersen, Rory Jensen, Ray Long, Rick Harvey, Cooper Gilkes),
7.5; Team Italia (Steve Baccelli, Mike Gagliardi), 6.5; Team Jumpin
Minnow (Tony Jackson, Tim Sheron, Chris Goeckel, William Pate), 6.25.
On the job
Elsewhere in the paper I describe the latest enforcement effort by
Sgt. Pat Grady, the environmental police officer (EPO) assigned to
the Vineyard since last July. Pat has begun picking up recreational
lobster traps to check that they meet state regulations.
Some fishermen used to doing things the way they want will undoubtedly
complain. And it is a change to have an EPO out enforcing state regulations.
But as he explained in the story, the regulations he is out enforcing
are ultimately designed to protect the resource, in this case lobsters.
A few weeks ago, I heard from several fishermen who were frustrated
and angry after witnessing what they said were other fishermen taking
short striped bass. Sergeant Grady said he has received reports, some
founded, some unfounded, and is trying to check all of the hot spots.
In one instance, he received a report of fishermen taking shorts at
Big Bridge and found men taking sea herring.
He said he will try to follow up on calls but needs people to try
and be more specific. Just saying that someone is taking shorts at
Big Bridge is not as helpful as providing a description of the vehicle
or fishermen involved.
A message may be left for Sergeant Grady at the EPO dispatch number,
1-800-632-8075, or at his Island office number, 508-696-8654.
The results are in
Last week, I described the e-mail exchange I had with a reader who
was offended by a comment I made about New Jersey in an earlier column.
He said there were just as many jackasses in Massachusetts as there
are in New Jersey (but a lot fewer highway exits), and compared me
to shock jock Howard Stern.
Because I consider this column to be something of an educational tool,
last week I announced that I would be conducting a web site poll in
which I asked computer literate readers to vote on the issues.
As of yesterday afternoon, we had received 48 responses to the question:
Are there about the same proportion of jackasses from Massachusetts
as from New Jersey?
The vote was close, 26 yes and 22 no. I have sent the results to the
Supreme Court for a clear decision.
Several voters added comments. Bruce, obviously a sensitive New Jersey
type, said,
Maybe glue up some MA/NJ plates to flip on
the boat and dodge the abuse
Tom took a more practical view. I try to fish in locations where
I won't run into jackasses of any kind. (Haven't been to Chappy in
years), but the few New Jersey guys I've met have always been real
gentlemen and sportsmen.
And Jeff could not resist a reply to Tom, telling him, but at
least they're from Massachusetts.
The other poll question generated less interest. A total of 15 voters
were in favor of adding Howard Stern cast members to The Times staff,
and eight disagreed.
The only comment was provided by my friend Ned who wrote,
Howard Stern? I was thinking more like Dear Abby.
Ask Nelson
Ned may have been closer to the truth than he knows. Yesterday, a
reader told me that he and a friend were out fishing off West Chop
when they spotted clouds of silversides in the water.
Apparently fishing was slow because they began to ponder where silversides
come from and how they arrive in our waters. He suggested I begin
a feature called, Ask Nelson. How it works is, you Ask Nelson, and
I ask, Anyone know where silversides come from?
Past
Favorites:
Fisherman
artist captures spirit of Derby grand slam, October 14, 2004
This
fishing Derby is not a man's world, October 7, 2004
59th
Bass and Bluefish Derby heads into home stretch, September 30, 2004
For
angler Olga Hirshhorn, a dream comes true,
September 23, 2004
59th
Derby off to quick, sometimes nutty start, September 16, 2004
Catch
some luck in the 59th annual bass and bluefish Derby, September 9,
2004
Tuna
madness big and small takes over the Island, September 2, 2004
Dr. Play
keeps his life's priorities in order, August 26, 2004
Derby welcomes three new members
to hall of fame, August 19, 2004
Commercial
fisherman finds literary success and fans, August 12, 2004
Fishermen
urged to play it safe on the water, August 5, 2004
First impressions
are lasting in the art of gyotaku, July 29, 2004
Big rods,
big fish, shark tournament draws a crowd, July 22, 2004
Mike
Amaral wears the crown of the fluke king, July 15, 2004
It's no fluke,
the tournament's this weekend, July 8, 2004
Chronicle
of Island fishing adventures, now a classic, is republished, July
1, 2004
Charter
captains weather costs and deliver fishing fun, June 24, 2004
Finding the
fish is the easy part, June 17, 2004
Game fly fishermen persevere in weekend
tourney, June 10, 2004
One fishing
photo is worth 1,000 words, June 3, 2004
Fishing
begins to heat up for the holiday weekend, May 27, 2004
Beginning
where this angler left off, May 20, 2004
Familiarity
breeds success in Kids' Trout Derby, May 13, 2004
Thieves
Steal Poles, Not Derby Spirit, October 16, 2003
Word
Always Gets Around in the 58th Derby, October 9, 2003
Kids Day
Derby Provides a Successful Fishing Bouillabaisse, October 2, 2003
Derby
Fishing Is a Challenge, but There Are Theories,
September 25, 2003
Changes in 58th Derby,
September 18, 2003
Good Derby Fishermen Know How to Prepare, September 11, 2003
King Livens Up the Vineyard Fishing Stage,
September 4, 2003
Fishless Angler Sets Off to See the Sights, August 28, 2003
Island Fishermen
Lured Offshore by Promise of Tuna,
August 21,2003
Island Bass Fishermen Survive,
August 14, 2003
When the Fish Arent Biting, Might As Well Do Chores, August
7, 2003
For Anglers,
It's Now Bonito Time,
July 31, 2003
Newest Derby
Inductees Are Hall of Famers in Any League, July 24, 2003
Fishermen
Do Not Get to Say Peep about Norton Point Beach Fee Hike, July 17,2003
Mon
Dieu, Winning Fish was Quite a Fluke, July 10, 2003
Prey and
Predator Confused On Buggy Night of Fishing, July 3, 2003
Pond Openings Hold Fish and Risk for Anglers, June 26, 2003
For an Angling Father,
Something Fishy's Always Welcome,
June 12, 2003
Despite
Pain of It, Anglers Carry On,
June 5, 2003
Fishing, Fishing
Supplies & Boat Charters Business Listing |