The Granite Store in Edgartown. —Sarah Shaw Dawson

Whether it’s for a shovel, fabric, or a greeting card, many Islanders’ one-stop-shop for non-food needs is Granite Five and Ten, the Edgartown hardware and general store.

But after people saw the building of the popular store, frequently just called Granite, listed for sale online, there were concerns for what’s seen as a linchpin for many residents’ last-minute and essential needs. 

“We’re still here,” Vanessa Grant, store manager, said Monday over the phone. “[Just] trying to do what we’re doing in this crazy economy.” 

The store building, at 224 Vineyard Haven Road, was listed for $5.9 million on commercial property listings like Crexi and Loopnet. The listing was up for over half a year but has since been taken down, as of Nov. 16. 

David Braga Jr., who is acting as principal for the family business and assets, said the listings were put up as a way to probe market demand and explore options. He said there was a lot of interest, and the family didn’t want to limit that interest only to people they knew. 

“We’re coming to an end of our little exercise now,” David Braga Jr. told the Times

Braga said his father, David Braga Sr., just turned 80, and the family is currently considering what to do with some of the properties they own for a “smooth transition.” 

Of those properties, the Granite store is the “premium asset,” and Braga Jr. said there’s been discussion about its future. Still, he assured The Times that no matter who owns the building, the current, “well-oiled” store operations will continue as before. On the Island, the Braga family also owns also owns a logistics center on 22 A Street in Edgartown near the Registry of Motor Vehicles.

“We’re not just looking for a check,” Braga Jr. said. “It would take a special individual to run an operation like that on Martha’s Vineyard.” 

Granite is located near the Edgartown Triangle and has served customers for four decades after Braga Sr. opened it in 1985. The first Granite store was founded by Frank Braga in 1947 in East Milton next to the Granite quarry in Quincy. 

Braga Jr. said that over the years, there’s been a lot of changes in the business landscape, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic, when there was a spike in business from a population surge. That’s since tapered off. Additionally, competition from big box stores and online retailers like Amazon make it so Granite needs active management to meet people’s needs at reasonable prices, whether that be nuts and bolts for year-round contractors or pillows for summertime rentals. 

Braga Jr. said “at the end of the day,” the family is probably not selling the store and improvements will instead be made to the store. But he didn’t completely rule out a sale “if the right person is there.” At the moment, Grant, current store manager, may be that person, who Braga Jr. said could be the store’s successor in around a decade. 

“But it takes a lot of work on this Island,” he said.

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *