A 96-year-old woman from West Tisbury who was a renowned painter and avid gardener was laid to rest in West Tisbury in a green burial in May, but according to a state trooper’s affidavit, a local funeral director alerted state officials with concerns about proper administrative procedures, prompting investigators to exhume her body in June.
The trooper’s affidavit said that Marie-Louise Rouff, who was an advocate for green burials in the town of West Tisbury, was buried fewer than 12 hours after her death without a permit, which was also not reported to the state’s medical examiner or the commonwealth for weeks.
The investigation by State Police Trooper Dustin T. Shaw led the chief medical examiner of Massachusetts to request that Rouff’s body be exhumed from the West Tisbury Village Cemetery, citing “potential for criminal activity, specifically elder abuse and neglect.” But no charges have occurred as a result of the investigation. An autopsy was performed on Rouff’s body by the state’s medical examiner on June 19, and her body was then reinterred to her grave. A lawyer representing Rouff’s estate has said that the autopsy violated her wishes to be buried naturally.
Questions surrounding Rouff’s burial and who should represent her interests came to light in a separate probate hearing that unfolded in recent weeks at the Dukes County Courthouse in Edgartown.
Rouff, who died on May 13, was born in Luxembourg in 1930, painted for more than 50 years, and settled on the Island in 2009 with her husband, Paul Levine. Her abstract paintings and monotypes were shown at Island galleries and collected publicly and privately in the U.S. and Europe. The Times profiled her work and her West Tisbury studio gallery several times, most recently in 2024.

“It’s been devastating for the family,” Geoghan Coogan, Rouff’s personal representative, said in a message to The Times. “[One of Rouff’s sons,] Michael [Pastreich,] traveled here multiple times to not just care for his mom but to ultimately lay her to rest, and then had to do so twice. The trauma alone of losing a parent is hard. To go through this scenario is just heartbreaking.”
Leonard Verville, funeral director of Chapman Funeral Homes in Oak Bluffs, told The Times he’d contacted State Police on June 11 because a handwritten death certificate he’d received from Martha’s Vineyard Hospital on May 13 listed Rouff’s causes of death as “critical polytrauma” and “fall, mechanical,” yet the manner of death was listed as “natural.”
Under Massachusetts law, deaths involving accidental or unintentional injury, including when a fall or blunt-force trauma contributed to the death, must immediately be reported to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (OCME). The statute places that duty on physicians, hospital administrators, and other medical personnel. But, according to Shaw’s affidavit, neither the medical examiner’s office nor the commonwealth was notified of Rouff’s death by the hospital prior to June 11. Verville said he also checked with the Oak Bluffs town clerk shortly after her death, around May 15, and found no death or burial paperwork on file.
“I didn’t have any reason not to follow up,” Verville said in an interview with The Times. “Polytrauma and natural death, that raised concerns.”
Verville said normally, when receiving a death certificate, he files it with the state shortly after, but because Rouff had requested a green burial and that no funeral homes be involved, it was out of his hands. It complicated an otherwise straightforward process.
The unusual exhumation occurred against a backdrop of how the families of loved ones, funeral directors, hospitals, and town cemeteries will handle a growing call for green burials, an environmentally conscious form of burial that doesn’t use embalming chemicals or concrete-encased caskets and allows the body to return to the earth through natural decomposition.
Rouff was in the forefront of a push in West Tisbury to clear the way for green burials. Her conviction that they are more natural, easier on the environment, and more affordable put her at odds with the lucrative funeral industry. The Times wrote about the green burial discussion and the opposing points of view represented at West Tisbury Town Hall by Rouff and by Island funeral director Verville in 2019.
Verville insists that none of Rouff’s history pushing for green burials had anything to do with alerting State Police and says that he was simply living up to his obligation to report an inconsistency in paperwork, a requirement of his profession.
At the time of death, Rouff’s body was transported from Martha’s Vineyard Hospital by family and, according to Shaw’s affidavit, buried with no applied-for or granted permits from West Tisbury fewer than 12 hours later. It takes several days to obtain those permits, Shaw wrote.
“Rouff’s death certificate had never been filed by the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital with the town or Commonwealth of Massachusetts, meaning that according to state records, it was as if Rouff was still living,” Shaw said in his affidavit.
The hospital has disputed the affidavit’s claims. Kelly Mitchell, public affairs program manager at the local hospital’s parent company Mass General Brigham in Boston, denied all the allegations regarding the hospital’s failing to notify town and state officials of Rouff’s death.
“The hospital calls these allegations inaccurate,” Mitchell said in an email to The Times.
Martha’s Vineyard Hospital doesn’t track final burial arrangements. Its usual process following a death at the hospital is to provide a death certificate to the funeral home. When a green burial is requested — which was the case here, according to Rouff’s attorney — the hospital files the death with a town clerk and only notifies the state’s medical examiner when required by Massachusetts law.
“Not only did Martha’s Vineyard Hospital fail to report and notify the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of Rouff’s death on May 13, 2026, they also failed to report her death in the days or weeks following, which resulted in a procedural failure and did not allow for the OCME jurisdictional decision to be made, and a record of her death was never recorded with the Commonwealth of Massachusetts,” Shaw said in his affidavit. “Additionally, it resulted in Rouff’s death not being thoroughly investigated by the OCME and the Massachusetts State Police, which resulted in an autopsy not being conducted, no collection of evidence, and no documentation of her injuries that she sustained on May 9, 2026, just four days prior to her death.”
Meanwhile, the Oak Bluffs town clerk, Amy Del Torto, said that because Rouff requested a green burial, and requested that no funeral home be involved in her burial, the clerk’s office created a death certificate for Rouff on May 18.
The office of Dr. Mindy Hull, the chief medical examiner of Massachusetts, took jurisdiction of the case on June 11, and an autopsy was eventually released on Sept. 23.
The autopsy from the chief medical examiner’s office determined that Rouff died of complications of blunt-force torso injuries and a fractured left hip. The manner of her death was ruled undetermined, but according to Shaw’s investigation, Rouff injured herself in a fall days before her death.
Exactly a week before she passed, one of Rouff’s sons, Emanuel Pastreich, called the Dukes County Regional Emergency Communications Center and said his mother had called him and said she was afraid for her safety.
West Tisbury Police went to Rouff’s home, but no one was there. Officers reached Rouff’s caregiver, who told police that Rouff was fine, according to the affidavit. The caregiver also told police that Pastreich “calls the police for unknown reasons,” and that Rouff was well cared for.
On May 9, days before she passed, a Life Alert system reported Rouff had fallen, according to the affidavit by Shaw. She was taken to Martha’s Vineyard Hospital and was admitted with multiple broken bones, including vertebrae and a hip. Rouff died four days later at the hospital, and the next morning, her family buried her in a green burial in West Tisbury.
The death has also become the center of a probate dispute among Pastreich, his siblings, and Coogan, the Edgartown attorney named as personal representative in Rouff’s will. Most recently, at the courthouse on Oct. 13, the court discussed Pastreich’s motion to remove Coogan as personal representative for Rouff’s estate handlings.
Pastreich, an Asia scholar and president of the Asia Institute, alleged in his objection affidavit submitted in July, and in emails to The Times, that his mother had been subjected to elder abuse and false imprisonment before her death, and that Coogan and the other heirs had sought to prevent the autopsy. He asked that estate funds be frozen until State Police released their findings.
Following the state’s decision to seek a warrant for Rouff’s body, Coogan filed an emergency motion in Dukes County Probate and Family Court asking to be appointed as special personal representative, arguing that exhuming the body was “in direct conflict” with Rouff’s wish for a green burial because the medical examiner’s common procedure was to cremate following a post-mortem autopsy.
Ultimately, the court ruled in favor of Coogan, striking Pastreich’s objection affidavit from the record and officially deeming Coogan personal representative for the remainder of Rouff’s post-life handlings. The objection means Pastreich’s claims are no longer before the court.
Michael Pastreich, brother to Emanuel, who lives in Maine, told investigators he had no concerns about abuse or neglect involving his mother and her caregiver, and believed her death was “her time,” the affidavit states.
The ruling allowed the family to move forward with handling Rouff’s estate under Coogan’s representation without Emanuel Pastreich challenging it moving forward.
Emanuel Pastriech said in an interview with The Times that he is considering changing his approach to a civil suit, and was surprised with the judge’s ruling despite the evidence before the court.





