Mr. Luening works with students in "Intro to Journalism." —Kate Hennigan

This story was inspired by an interview led by students in Ms. Hennigan’s senior “Journalism” elective. 

Many seniors at the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School (MVRHS) know Erich Luening as “the Super Sub” — a friendly and outgoing permanent substitute teacher on staff who goes out of his way to support kids emotionally and academically, and even in their work as budding journalists. What they may not know is that he, too, was once a 17-year-old Island kid who sat in these classrooms, struggling with the questions of what to do after high school. 

After graduating in 1986, Mr. Erich (as he’s affectionately called) chose to enlist in the U.S. Army, feeling that college was not within reach at that time.

“My friends were all leaving for college,” Mr. Erich said. “I was here on the Island, and I just saw ahead 10, 20 years. I was like, What am I going to do, you know, staying here? Do I want to get into college? I didn’t have a father around, and joining the Army was part of wanting to be challenged as a young man.” 

The basic training Mr. Erich received in South Carolina introduced him to the reality of the military.  “They woke us up at like 4:30 am banging things, and I was like, Gosh, this is for real. And then later that day, two old sergeants were yelling and screaming. I was like, Did I make the right decision?” he said. 

Harsh wake-up calls and drill sergeants yelling at him made him question whether or not joining the Army was the right choice. Despite this, Mr. Erich soon found that he could get used to a demanding environment. 

“It taught me for the first time that I could handle it on my own. I had never felt that way,” he said.

Mr. Erich said that his most important takeaway from his time in the military was learning to adapt to new environments and to make difficult decisions. He believes that to a large extent the Army shaped him into the man he is today — it even inspired his teaching career, as he believes he can relate to students who may feel lost, and perhaps be the man for them that he didn’t have.

After serving in the Army for four years, Mr. Erich returned to the Island, where he put his Army medic training to use at Martha’s Vineyard Hospital before enrolling at Boston University and graduating from its journalism program. Since working as a freelance reporter, Mr. Erich has won several press awards, including the Society of Professional Journalism award for online feature writing. He currently works as a correspondent for the Cape and Islands NPR station, WCAI.  

While he loves his work as a reporter, his heart is in teaching, too. “I didn’t know that I wanted to be a teacher until I came here four years ago,” he said. 

Erich says people are often shocked to learn he is a veteran. “All my family were Unitarian ministers, teachers, librarians,” he said. “And there were a lot of misconceptions. One of my family members at a dinner table before I left [for the Army] asked, ‘How could you join the army of the country that enslaves your people?’ That was a while ago. It’s a good question. I said, Yeah, slavery. But then there was no slavery. Because Americans fought in the Civil War and freed the enslaved. For me, it’s worth defending that,” he said.

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *