Based on election results, it is safe to say many Island voters are heartened by the outcome of November’s midterm election, and the “blue wave” that came with it. But perhaps those who have a reason to have a reason to feel most hopeful are immigrants who cannot vote, but who call the Island home. Whatever their personal politics are, they are likely to be . Whatever their personal politics are, they are likely to be deeply impacted by the stunning rebuke to Donald Trump and his policies, particularly his harsh crackdown on immigration. Immigrants to the Island and across the commonwealth may also be buoyed by Gov. Maura’s Healey’s so-called Protect Act to prohibit immigration arrests in schools, childcare centers, healthcare facilities, nursing homes, and courthouses. The new law, which was passed in August, is also intended to restrict state and local police from using public facilities and resources to aid federal immigration enforcement, and limits when law enforcement can ask about immigration. As we report this week, Dukes County Sheriff Robert (“Bob”) W. Ogden and 11 other Massachusetts sheriffs are appealing to Healey to amend the law to address what they feel is a public safety gap in the way the new law is structured.
Amid this backdrop, and with two more years ahead with President Trump in the White House, many immigration advocates and immigrants themselves, who have been living in fear of ICE raids, are asking important questions:
- Will Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents suddenly become more humane?
- Will those subject to deportation suddenly have greater access to immigration courts and due process before the U.S. deports them without a hearing, access to a lawyer, or a day in court? And will local detention centers be monitored, and made less horrific?
- Will the U.S. stop sending detainees to third countries where they have no roots, and where they may face persecution?
- When they are returned to their home countries, will they receive guarantees that they will not be subject to imprisonment, torture, or death?
In the aftermath of the midterm election, there is a political question front and center: Has the often erratic President Trump changed his mind about his immigration policies? He told “60 Minutes” journalist Ross Douthat on Nov. 8 that he now realizes he has been “too tough” in ordering people out of the country.
Unfortunately, it seems the answer is no to just about all the above questions. One sign that we can expect little change from the executive branch — and perhaps an even further deterioration of the rule of law — is Trump’s appointment of immigration czar Stephen Miller as the new White House chief of staff. Here are some of the reasons why we should expect the U.S. government to continue to threaten all undocumented immigrants, including those on the Island.
The number of detention centers has sharply grown since the beginning of the second Trump administration, from 134 to 272. Stephen Miller’s fingerprints are all over what the American Civil Liberties Union calls his “draconian mass detention and deportation agenda.”
Miller was the chief architect of the family separation policy, as a senior advisor in the first Trump administration. The policy lasted from 2017 to 2018, and ended after a universal denunciation from both Democrats and Republicans. While the number of children taken from their families is still imprecise, the U.S. itself reported a minimum of 3,913 children separated from their families after their parents were arrested and detained. Many journalists use a number closer to 5,500.
According to a study in the medical journal Pediatrics, several doctors found that the treatment of detained children amounted to torture under international law. The physicians noted that “the treatment of children at the border constitutes cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment that rises to the level of torture.”
Miller was also responsible for helping craft the first so-called Muslim ban executive order that Trump signed after he was inaugurated in January 2017. The Supreme Court tossed it out as unconstitutional, but later approved a third version because it included non-Muslim countries whose residents were forbidden to enter the country.
In addition, there’s Miller’s use of the obscure 1798 Alien Enemies Act, which until 2025 the U.S. had deployed just three times: during the War of 1812, World War I, and World War II. The New York Times wrote that Miller’s “most audacious immigration move came in the form of a presidential proclamation, which Mr. Trump used to invoke the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 and deport Venezuelan immigrants accused of being members of the Tren de Aragua street gang.” According to Human Rights Watch, the U.S. sent detainees to the notorious 40,000-inmate CECOT prison in El Salvador, where prisoners faced isolation, overcrowding, torture, and death. There is no evidence that federal agents sent any Island immigrants to CECOT.
Miller was also the lead advocate to secure $170 billion in funding for ICE in the so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill” passed in summer of 2025, with $45 billion allocated to build detention centers. This funding also triggered the deployment of hundreds of many poorly trained ICE agents to Minneapolis (and other cities throughout the country), leading to agents killing two Americans, Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti. The Washington Post has documented many ICE agents who were hired without proper vetting. According to one high official in the Department of Homeland Security, “a hiring process like this — where it’s quick and you’re missing stuff, as we’ve seen — inevitably that results in hiring people that probably shouldn’t have been.”
The New York Times investigated an ICE agent killing of an unarmed Colombian man in Biddeford, Maine, last July, and as one example, found that the ICE agent involved had “a troubling work history, domestic violence and abuse complaints, mental health issues, and virulent anti-immigrant views.”
Finally, Miller has argued that the U.S. must deport at a minimum 3,000 immigrants a day. Annualizing the numbers is easy: In one year, that means more than a million people detained and deported. Island residents vulnerable to this policy are deeply at risk. Most detainees have no serious criminal records, though some may have committed minor misdemeanors. According to the American Immigration Council, “The single largest increase in ICE detention usage is among people who have had no interactions with the criminal justice system at all, who are being arrested in these brand-new sweeping policies, such as the use of roving patrols, worksite raids, and the arrest of people at courthouses and immigration check-ins.”
Undocumented residents on the Island are now more deeply at risk than ever before. ICE agents were on the Island in May 2025 and made several arrests. It is unremarkable to predict that they will return. When they do, they will seek not the “worst of the worst,” as the Trump administration initially promised. They will target anyone with nonwhite skin, including children, and send them to horrific and cruel detention centers and then cruelly deport them.
All of this means that the newly elected Democratic majority in the U.S. House and Senate, and newly elected governors and incumbents such as Healey, will have a tough battle ahead if they are going to uphold the rule of law and restore America’s promise and its once-proud history as a nation made by immigrants.
MVTimes essayist Jack Fruchtman, who lives in Aquinnah, taught constitutional law and politics for more than 40 years.

