Updated Oct. 28 at 11:55 am.
The only nonprofit and shelter that assists unhoused people on the Island is entering the fall season with a new shelter director and a plan, as homelessness on Martha’s Vineyard continues to rise.
Harbor Homes has several changes underway as the annual winter shelter gets set to open on Nov. 1. The winter shelter will be located at St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church in Edgartown this year, as the new permanent building the organization secured in Vineyard Haven is renovated; the process to find a permanent place took several years, and received pushback from potential neighbors. But the season before its next chapter begins, Harbor Homes is returning to its roots: St. Andrew’s in Edgartown, where the winter shelter began in 2016.
After years at churches during the colder months, Harbor Homes’ winter shelter nailed down a more stable spot at the Martha’s Vineyard Community Services campus in 2022. But due to the construction planned for the area, the shelter had to relocate after the 2024–25 winter season. Last year, the winter shelter was temporarily located at Harbor Homes women’s congregate housing at 111 New York Ave. on Oak Bluffs, through a zoning allowance from the town.
“We are grateful to St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church for once again opening its doors to our winter shelter guests,” Jeannette de Jesús, executive director of Harbor Homes, stated in a press release Monday. “This partnership reflects the generosity and commitment of our Island community to ensuring that our neighbors experiencing homelessness have a safe place to stay and access to essential services during the coldest months of the year.”

The new permanent shelter, located at 515 Edgartown–Vineyard Haven Road in Vineyard Haven, is slated to be completed by Oct. 1 of next year, but could be done even sooner, de Jesús said. As construction continues, and the shelter opens in a temporary location for what could be the last time in the nonprofit’s history, Harbor Homes administrators said they’re excited for the future.
“We’re really thrilled that we’re going to have a permanent shelter,” de Jesús told The Times on Monday.
According to the release, the winter shelter served 58 individuals last season, and the number of people in need of an overnight stay is projected to increase this year. While de Jesús said there’s “no reliable projection of homelessness on the Vineyard,” there was a peak in the number of people without a home in January 2026. She said there’s no single indication, and the weather was “particularly bad,” but the data point to a rise. She added that “considerable shortages of affordable housing on the Island support our concern that homelessness is increasing.”
“Across Cape Cod, Nantucket and [the] Vineyard, homelessness was up more than 35 percent,” she told The Times. “These regional figures may indicate that homelessness is on the rise, and there will be more pressure for services.”
Harbor Homes also announced the appointment of Mary Alley as the new shelter director in Monday’s press release. Lisa Belcastro was the previous winter shelter director, a position she was appointed to in 2020 and held until last February, when she resigned. After Belcastro left Harbor Homes, volunteers Pat and Polly Toomey were appointed as temporary co-directors.

Alley joined Harbor Homes in May, according to the release, and worked with shelter leadership, staff, and volunteers on summer programs and plans for the winter shelter. Her work as the director of the winter shelter will include daily operations and oversight of the volunteers and shelter.
“Having grown up on the Island, taking care of my neighbors has always been important to me,” Alley said in the release. “A few years ago, I learned about the important work Harbor Homes does, which inspired me to volunteer and begin my journey with the organization. I believe deeply in Harbor Homes’ mission, and look forward to working with our team and community partners to help our clients find a path to stability.”
The overnight winter shelter at St. Andrew’s will be open seven nights a week through April 18. The shelter is open from 6 pm each night until 8 am the following morning. Guests receive an evening meal and breakfast, and have access to showers and laundry. Harbor Homes also provides access to social services and health resources, according to the release.
Editor’s note: Updated to include more information about previous winter shelter directors and details about homelessness being on the rise.


Congratulations, Mary! Couldn’t have happened to a better, more competent person! The old saying, “when one door closes, another one opens” rings true.