Updated Nov. 4.
A home in Tisbury was condemned by town officials Oct. 27 after an inspection revealed alleged overcrowded conditions, which town records indicate had been a pattern for more than three years.
The condemned home on 182 Lake St. is owned by Khanh and Quynh Tran, who also go by the first names John and Selena, and allegedly housed more than the 10 approved occupants. The couple owns the local business Hollywood Nails on Circuit Avenue as well as several other residential properties in Tisbury and Oak Bluffs, according to real estate records. They purchased 182 Lake St. in 2010, and it’s unclear how long they have rented out the property. Board of health and building department records state the couple is based in Falmouth.
Overcrowded homes on the Island are even more common than health reports suggest, especially in workplace housing and within the Brazilian community, according to health officials, regional data, and past reporting by The Times.
According to data collected by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission and other sources regarding population and housing conditions, the number of non-family households on the Vineyard has risen by 40 percent in the last decade. In the same time frame, the number of local households with more than four people has grown by 29 percent. It’s uncertain whether this is a last resort or whether landlords charge lower rent in these conditions, though The Times has reported on overcrowded accommodations where the cost for rent was comparable to or higher than average rents on the Vineyard.
Many of these homes go unreported. The Lake Street home is an example of what occurs when town officials cite landlords for overcrowding: The tenants have to leave. This fear of displacement often prevents tenants from reporting conditions in their own accommodations, according to past reporting by The Times. While landlords are required to rehouse tenants for a short time after a home is condemned, it’s not a long-term solution.
At a Tisbury board of health meeting on Oct. 27, health agent Drew Belsky presented a report on the condemned home. Board members said they recognized the home as a property with many cars in the front yard.
“I was originally supposed to attend housing court tomorrow, for an injunction on this property. But the owner complied to allow us to go do an inspection there [Monday, Oct. 26],” Belsky said in the meeting. “After the inspection with the building and fire department and town administration, the building department did condemn the building.”
There were no cars in the driveway the morning of Oct. 28, the day after the meeting. Instead, an old boat was propped up on the lawn and a purple bouncer for a baby was on the porch. A bright red condemnation notice was attached to the door. The home looked abandoned.

The Trans, whom The Times tried to reach through Hollywood Nails and through a personal number, didn’t respond for comment.
The first complaint that referenced overcrowding at the Lake Street home was in 2023, when Maura Valley was the health agent. Valley wrote a letter to the Trans that said the board had received “complaints of severe overcrowding.”
She wrote that the location of the home on the Lagoon Pond watershed, one of the most sensitive watersheds on the Island to increased nitrogen, made adherence to the septic capacity of greater importance. Valley noted that the maximum capacity of the home was 10 occupants across five bedrooms. But floor plans and records of the property from this year show eight bedrooms listed for the home, which is located on a parcel of more than 16,000 square feet.
“Overcrowded living conditions impact septic systems, and, under current board of health nitrogen regulations, your system will need to be replaced with an advanced nitrogen removal system should it fail,” Valley wrote in 2023. Lagoon Pond has been a part of Tisbury’s denitrification efforts of local watersheds.
Based on reports from this August, that observation from Valley came to pass. On August 3, the town issued a notice to the Trans that their sewage disposal system had failed. After two pump-outs were conducted on the property within 30 days in July and early August, Belsky conducted an inspection of the home. Health officials found additional bedrooms in the basement and attic.
In the attic, there were “clear signs of occupancy by a family” observed by Belsky. This included a living room space, bathroom, small closet, and three beds.
After the notice of septic failure, the homeowners filed a complete septic system repair permit application. It was filed on August 13 and cited the applicant’s intention to upgrade to a nine-bedroom capacity. The request was approved by the town.
Still, the town is enforcing the condemnation and seeking “injunctive relief” in Southeast Housing Court, according to court documents. The town’s original complaint was filed Sept. 25, and the next hearing was at 10 am on Nov. 4. That hearing wasn’t held virtually, and The Times made an audio request that wasn’t completed until after the print deadline.
Action through the courts is not the first course for town officials; it usually occurs if a property owner has not complied with previous warnings or orders.
“The town seeks preliminary and permanent injunctive relief requiring that defendants immediately remedy the outstanding violations that exist on the property,” the complaint reads. “The ongoing violations present potential health and safety hazards to the occupants of the property, abutters, and the general public.”
It’s unclear how many occupants were staying in the home prior to condemnation, but they moved out within 48 hours, according to health officials.
“The condemnation gave 24-hour notice of vacating the premises, which we followed up on at noon today,” Belsky said at the meeting on Oct. 27.
Belsky told the board that the chain of events with 182 Lake St. is setting a precedent for how they handle similar situations in the town.
“This one we were fortunate to get our foot in the door with a failed septic, and I got a walk-through that initiated all of the urgency with all of this, but we are at least setting a blueprint for how we handle this going forward,” Belsky said.
Editor’s note: This is the print version of this article and includes most recent updates, as of Nov. 4.


Is anyone seriously surprised by this? Overcrowded houses on Martha’s Vineyard are hardly a new phenomenon. The real question is why this has been allowed to continue for so long.
The numbers tell the story. According to Massachusetts housing data, 61% of Vineyard homes are designated for seasonal or occasional use, while the Island’s population increased 24% between 2012 and 2022.The MV Times reported last year that households with more than four people had increased 29% over approximately a decade.
In 2018, one Edgartown property was investigated after officials found 34 beds. Seven years later, overcrowding was again reported at that property. Now we learn that complaints about this Tisbury house date back to 2023.
Meanwhile, our roads, wastewater systems, natural resources, and public services face mounting pressure.
This is not about blaming people desperate for a roof over their heads. It’s about years of inadequate enforcement and an unwillingness to confront the Island’s finite capacity.
We keep treating overcrowding as an isolated violation while continuing to encourage the very growth that makes it inevitable. At what point do we stop pretending the Island has unlimited room? Apparently, approving still more development is easier than acknowledging the obvious reality.
I am sure ALOT more could be found around the island if investigated. What a sham it took this long from the early reports