A Lake Street home in Tisbury was condemned by health officials after septic system issues and alleged overcrowding. —Sarah Shaw Dawson

New details have emerged about an alleged overcrowded home in Tisbury condemned by the building department weeks ago as the town takes the homeowners to court for what they describe as repeated negligence of the health and safety of tenants.

The home, at 182 Lake St., is owned by Khanh and Quynh Tran, who also go by John and Selena. The couple also owns Hollywood Nails in Oak Bluffs and several other homes in Tisbury and Oak Bluffs, according to real estate records. According to town correspondence, the couples’ permanent residence is in Falmouth.

The town, in a request for preliminary and permanent injunctive relief from the court, alleges that the homeowners violated the state sanitary, building code, and fire safety codes. Through the preliminary and permanent injunction, the town requests that the defendants “immediately remedy the outstanding violations that exist on the property.” 

The violations are more detailed in an amended complaint, which contains photographs, by the town, and according to Tisbury Health Agent Drew Belsky, have not been addressed by the Trans as of Monday, Nov. 16. But because the tenants of the home haven’t lived there since right before the most recent inspection by town officials, the timeline to apply for permits to comply with the violations is longer than it would be if tenants were present. 

“Occupancy won’t be able to be gained until they have compliance and inspections,” Belsky said during a phone interview with The Times. “They haven’t done any work on bringing the building into compliance other than the septic system.”

The amended complaint was filed by Tisbury officials on Nov. 3, and a closed-door hearing was held on Nov. 4 in Southeast Housing Court in Barnstable.

Belsky, one of the first town officials made aware of the situation at the Lake Street home, told The Times that situations like this are “never easy.” 

“Especially on this Island where [housing] is already difficult to obtain,” Belsky added.

Overcrowded living as a solution to a looming crisis in housing affordability is, more often than not, dangerous to the tenants, homeowners, home, or the environment. And data show that overcrowded conditions on the Vineyard are increasingly common. In 2025, the Martha’s Vineyard Commission found that within the last decade, the number of households consisting of non-family members on the Vineyard rose by 40 percent, and the number of local households with more than four people grew by 29 percent. 

Overcrowded living comes up in another context through state data. The projected change in housing demand on the Vineyard between 2025 and 2035 found that “latent demand” from overcrowded housing, doubling-up, and living with parents to be the most significant need in the next decade, with an estimated 430 additional units needed to house future tenants or homeowners.  

The home on Lake Street was one documented example of alleged overcrowding, but town officials maintain that many others go unreported. And Belsky said nothing is known about the tenants and their current situation after leaving the Lake Street property. While landlords are required by law to rehome tenants when violations like overcrowding occur, the tenants were gone before that could be fully enforced and documented. 

The septic system and building at 182 Lake St. allowed for five-bedrooms and up to 10 occupants. But according to health records, the home actually had eight bedrooms, with two in the basement and one in the attic, and at least three unpermitted bathrooms. In the first complaint filed on Sept. 25, Belsky said there were “clear signs of occupancy by a family” in the attic apartment. The property housed an unknown number of individuals. 

The septic system was under strain from the additional occupants and overflowed twice this summer, which alerted the health department to the issue, as was the case three years ago. The first notice about alleged overcrowding at the home was in 2023, submitted by then-Tisbury Health Agent Maura Valley. 

Since the home is located on the Tashmoo Pond watershed and a nitrogen overlay district, there was heightened concern of added nitrogen through waste in the area. After the septic overflowed twice this summer and emergency pump-outs were required on July 9 and August 3, current health agent Belsky sent an order to mitigate the overflow to the Trans. 

On August 13, the Trans applied for a disposal system construction permit for the Lake Street home and submitted documents that showed the building contained eight bedrooms. The application for a septic system upgrade was approved by Belsky on August 18, and he did a walk-through of the home on the same day.

Two days after that walk-through, Belsky sent a second order: to cease unapproved wastewater flow and schedule another inspection with the board of health, building department, and fire department.

The updated complaint states that “upon opinion and belief, a new septic system was installed” at the Lake Street home “on or around Sept[.] 23.” About a month later, the Trans allowed the town department heads access to the home, and they conducted a second inspection on Oct. 26 when they “observed serious code violations concerning life and safety,” according to the complaint.

During the second walk-through, the town officials saw few egresses or exits, mattresses leaned against the walls and on the floor, curtains used as makeshift door coverings, exposed wires and cables, and unpermitted basement wiring, outlets, and fixtures. 

They observed few ways to exit, including several that were blocked. The basement stairwell was boarded up, obstructing a secondary means of exit for the tenants of the two unpermitted apartments there. There were no windows, skylights, mechanical ventilation, or doors to the exterior in one of the basement apartments. In the other, there was a small, horizontal sliding window, but no other ventilation or exit. 

After that inspection, the building commissioner issued a condemnation notice.

When The Times visited the home on Monday, not much had changed from when The Times first reported on the condemned home on Oct. 28. Red notices were still pasted on the door, next to light blue shingles on the building’s exterior. A small boat was now gone from a patch of dirt near the driveway, and a purple baby bouncer was removed from the front porch. A half-dozen potted plants were new additions in the front yard. There were no cars in the driveway or any indication that people lived there, besides the items that were left behind. The home still looked recently abandoned.

The next hearing for the request of preliminary injunction is scheduled for Dec. 9 at 10 am in Southeast Housing Court.

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *