In the early hours of Nov. 1, a cacophony of low voices echoed through the woods in West Tisbury.
“You’re cutting it close on this side,” Bob Hayden, owner of Hayden Movers, called out to Riley Dobel, owner of Tabor Tree Service, at 7 am as Dobel navigated a large work truck. “Turn an inch to your right!”
Dobel twisted the wheel in response to Hayden’s direction. The team was approaching hour three out in the woods, making minute movements to the left and right to avoid hitting the towering trees lining a dirt pass off Old County Road. More specifically, they were avoiding any damage to the precious and unusual cargo that was attached to the truck’s trailer: a small home.
The house — complete with dark gray shingles, a pitched roof, a gutter wrapping around the perimeter, and a small staircase to the front door — was slated to be demolished by Vineyard Haven and Edgartown marina company Safe Harbor. That is, until David Bouck, a local resident and research manager for Martha’s Vineyard Shellfish Group, asked if he could take it off their hands instead.
Relocating an entire house that was slated for demolition is not a new idea, but it is viewed as one of many viable housing solutions on the Island. High housing costs have priced many working year-rounders out of ownership, and affordable rentals are rare. Moving a house that would otherwise be smashed to bits has another benefit: It saves a significant amount of waste, which is its own problem on the Island.
When Safe Harbor agreed to the exchange, which also meant avoiding a costly demolition, Bouck embarked on a long process of gathering permits and allowances. He hired movers (Hayden) and a tree-removal company (Dobel), and secured a police escort. Finally, that Sunday morning, after almost half a year of logistics, Bouck stood on his parcel of land in West Tisbury, and watched as the move unfolded.
The entire process and house cost Bouck around $25,000 — much less than the median home price of $1.6 million on Martha’s Vineyard. And while the house is small in stature, at 288 square feet (about the size of a one-car garage), it represents more for Bouck, a working Island resident in his mid-30s. It’s a home to call his own.
“It feels amazing that it’s done. It was quite the effort,” Bouck said in an interview with The Times after the move. “It involved a lot of coordination with a lot of different people [and] a lot of different entities … The stars had to align for it to work out, and they did.”
House moves, like Bouck’s, do happen on the Island. Homes attached to large trucks, with a sign that reads “OVERSIZE LOAD,” both led and tailed by police cruisers that flash their hazards, are even seen on main roads, most often in early morning hours.
And the practice goes back centuries. In the 1986 Dukes County Intelligencer, a former regional history journal published by the Martha’s Vineyard Museum, a house move in 1822 was detailed. That year, the document states, the Joseph Norton House on Cooke Street in Edgartown was moved “by the help of stalwart men, strong oxen, and good Jamaica rum.”
Nowadays, a house move is slightly more complex and definitely more technologically advanced, as Bouck found out quickly. Instead of oxen, they used a truck. In the place of Jamaica rum, a sobering chill lingered in the early hours that Sunday. The “stalwart men” are the only constant through the centuries.
But house moves used to be more common, partly because of the permitting process that’s now legally required. (Oxen don’t cut it anymore.) There are, however, emergent efforts to streamline the process. Bouck found some of those resources on his journey, including a cost-assistance nonprofit and Edgartown Health Agent Brice Boutot, who said he “was fortunate to be involved with a similar project last winter” and shared his experience with Bouck.
Boutot told The Times that “there’s no single solution for the housing crisis,” but “utilizing demolition delay bylaws to relocate existing houses can absolutely help with housing affordability, and it is mutually beneficial when done right.”
“An Islander can potentially save hundreds of thousands in exorbitant building costs, while the existing property owner simultaneously saves on demolition and can receive a tax benefit by donating the house, which is itself saved from a landfill,” Boutot wrote in an email.
Boutot said moving a house in this way does require coordination between town officials, like the building department, select board, and affordable housing committee. The process can get even more complicated when a house moves across town lines. “While this is achievable, it can feel like the stars must be aligned to pull it off,” he wrote, echoing Bouck’s sentiments.
One way Boutot helped Bouck was connecting him with John Abrams, clerk and founder of the Island Affordable Housing Fund and co-founder of South Mountain Co. One of the purposes of the fund is to save structures slated for demolition and restrict them for year-round occupancy.
“We have done three of those so far,” Abrams told The Times on Tuesday. “And we hope to do more.”
Abrams said in the early 2000s, the Island Affordable Housing Fund moved about a dozen houses and made them into affordable housing. For some of those, their strategy was to find a home set to be demolished, get it appraised, and offer the homeowners that amount in tax deductions in exchange for donating the structure. “People did that over and over,” he said. “It was incredible.”
He said his intention is to make house moves easier and more cost-effective on the Vineyard, a place where about one in two residents spends more than half of their income on their rent or mortgage. Meanwhile, he said the process could be made even better if more towns expand their demolition delay bylaws to six months.
“These buildings are going to the dump, and someone less fortunate gets a house. That’s what this is all about on the Vineyard.”
Bob Hayden
Currently, all Island towns have a demolition delay bylaw. For most towns, this bylaw requires that the owner of any home slated for demolition give 30 days’ notice to the town. In that 30-day window, locals can bid on the home (in theory). But an expanded demolition delay bylaw is recommended to be six months instead, as outlined in the 2024 Zoning Analysis for Housing Solutions by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission (MVC). Movement on this front is occuring. West Tisbury already passed an expanded demolition delay bylaw to six months, and Chilmark and Edgartown are drafting theirs.
An expanded six-month demolition delay bylaw was also passed on Nantucket with overwhelming approval in 2024. According to reporting by BlueDot Living, the bylaw is already yielding results and waste reduction; Nantucket moved 84 structures that year. “Nantucket has this down to a science,” Boutot said, “and moves more houses than anywhere else in the state.” The Vineyard, on the other hand, is still figuring out all the quirks in all the towns.
Relocation can be used as a way to save historic buildings, which is relevant on the Island where there are more than 2,000 older structures. The commission found that while around 930 historic buildings on the Island are located in one of six historic districts, which subjects them to detailed review by town historical commissions, the majority of historic buildings (about 1,460) are outside those districts. For those, there are limited protections in regard to demolition.

While not a historic house, Bouck’s journey still saved a small cottage set for demolition by Safe Harbor. The company wanted to upgrade its year-round housing options for staff, and Chris Scott, the marina general manager, said the decision to start anew was due to the state of the older workforce housing structures. They started the process in 2022, and just cut the ribbon on a set of new duplexes, located at 80 Lagoon Pond Road, on Nov. 10.
“We needed to add to our employee housing stock, as we had all of our housing full already with year-round employees,” Scott said in an email to The Times. “At the time, we had three cottages that were 30 to 45 years old, and in some disrepair.”
Scott said two of the cottages were demolished in 2025 for about $30,000 total, and since a staff member was living in the third cottage for a little longer, it was still standing when Bouck approached them about moving it to a parcel he owns. Scott found the proposition to be mutually beneficial, and agreed to the move. He sold the house for $1 to Bouck.
“I think moving some smaller structures is a great idea for those looking to create some flexible ADU [accessory dwelling unit] options and housing options,” Scott said. “I’m not sure how feasible it is on a larger scale.”
A company or individual might look at demolition because an old house has rotting wood, and it is worth scrapping the materials. But structurally sound homes are often demolished to make room for new buildings, as was the case with Safe Harbor.
In 2025, Bouck reached out to the West Tisbury building inspector for approval of the move. Since that’s the town where three acres he and his family own are located, and where the house would end up, he thought he’d start there. The town signed off, so Bouck called Hayden and began the moving process. When they were moving the cottage onto a trailer bed, however, the Tisbury building inspector, Greg Monka, happened to drive by and said they needed a permit. So to the town of Tisbury Bouck went.
Bouck said he was told to fill out a permit application, called the Tisbury Move a Building Permit, which includes health and safety checks, road clearing, insurance, and additional requirements. Then he had to secure a police escort and make sure the roads were clear for travel with Hayden and Dobel. Dobel was cutting small tree limbs to clear a path for the house two days prior to the move.
The culmination of Bouck’s efforts — and that of those helping him — finally happened, starting at 4 am on Nov. 1. It took Hayden 45 minutes to drive with the house to Old County Road from Vineyard Haven. When they arrived at Bouck’s road, Dobel took a break from cutting trees to sit in Hayden’s driver’s seat. With the home behind the truck and a road nearly as wide as the house itself, each bend and curve took up to an hour to navigate.
The Times arrived on Bouck’s land as the sun was rising, at about 6:30 am. The house was moving like a puzzle piece into a larger picture — every movement with the truck was loud, yet minuscule. Every direction was hastily yelled across the dirt road they drove on. And, as Dobel put it, “every inch was like a win.”
The entire process, even with the hurdles and the time spent, was a “win” to the people involved. The materials from house demolitions, which go into an excavator to be crushed and end up in a dumpster, are often shipped off-Island, using fuel, resources, and time. Dobel, who sees the number of trees that are either shipped off-Island or shaved into chips for landscaping, said he was “happy to do [his] part” and “help a born-and-raised Islander actually get a house.”
Hayden agreed that moving a home is a sound solution, but told The Times that he hopes the towns organize a more streamlined process. Having six towns, six collections of zoning bylaws, and varied permitting processes complicates house moves on the Vineyard, especially in Bouck’s case, as the home was moved from one town to another.
“There should be some sort of a group, like a consortium of people that gets together and starts to think about this, because [the Vineyard is] way behind the town of Nantucket, which started this 25 years ago, and really, really got behind this,” Hayden said.
Hayden’s moving company is based in Marston Mills, but often operates locally. He said there’s room on the Vineyard for more house moves like Bouck’s, and he hopes to see more concerted action.
“These buildings are going to the dump, and someone less fortunate gets a house,” Hayden said of the process. “That’s what this is all about on the Vineyard.”
This is the third in an ongoing series by housing and health reporter Sarah Shaw Dawson on proposed solutions for the Island community in the face of a housing crisis related to affordability, supply, policy, and the environment.

