To the Editor:
The statement by Island sheriffs that the PROTECT Act is a danger to public safety aims at the wrong target. To the extent that the release of “individuals charged with serious or violent crimes” poses a danger to public safety, that is an issue for a bond hearing before the criminal court. The sheriffs do not at all articulate why releasing noncitizens is more of a danger than releasing citizens on the same bail. In fact, noncitizens do not pose any greater risk to the community. Moreover, outsourcing detention to ICE is bad policy.
First, like any citizen, a noncitizen is also entitled to the presumption of innocence. Second, the commonwealth may argue in any case that bail should be denied or set high, particularly if there is an articulated flight risk and/or danger to the community. Third, relying on ICE, with its record of abuse and practice of moving detainees far across the country and denying them access to counsel, is inhumane, and could deprive the commonwealth of an opportunity to prosecute the accused or to obtain evidence from them.
The Island and the commonwealth are safer without cooperation with ICE to separate families.
Steven H. Schulman, Esq.
Edgartown

