Updated Nov. 4.
The Edgartown zoning board of appeals (ZBA) unanimously voted to refer the already controversial Edgartown Cove project to the Martha’s Vineyard Commission (MVC) during its first review Oct. 28, but a consultant hired by the town said a state ruling from the spring complicates the matter. In a divergence from the norm, it was ultimately determined that until the state legislature decides the fate of the MVC, this project will be reviewed by the town.
The uncertain territory referenced at the meeting played out hours prior to the hearing in interviews conducted by The Times with the MVC and the developer; both disagreed about the current authority of the regional board over this project after a state ruling discredited the MVC. Meanwhile, the proposed development drew concerns from Islanders and abutters, who submitted letters before the hearing, about the septic capacity and environmental impact on the land and watershed.
Edgartown Cove, which is proposed as a two-story apartment building with 40 units at 501 West Tisbury Road in Edgartown, is a new Chapter 40B development by Falmouth-based developer William Cumming. It includes 30 market-rate one- and three-bedrooms that are projected to cost between $700,000 and $1.1 million each, and 10 affordable units that have cost projections between $157,700 and $186,359, according to materials submitted by the developer.
Chapter 40B is a state statute that allows developers to curb local zoning if a housing development includes a quarter of affordable units, like Edgartown Cove would. But on an Island with limited land and a seasonal housing market, Chapter 40B projects can be more complex.
Cumming is the largest developer of Chapter 40B projects on the Vineyard. His past proposals include Edgartown Gardens, a 60-unit complex planned near Donaroma’s Nursery that was unanimously denied by the MVC late last year, a decision that had unintended consequences for the regional board. Green Villa, another of Cumming’s projects, is a 116-unit condominium complex planned for Oak Bluffs that was narrowly approved with numerous conditions by the MVC.
The towns’ ZBAs are required to refer projects to the MVC, a regional planning body tasked with reviewing developments in Dukes County, when a development proposed is large or impactful. After zoning board members voted to refer the project to the MVC during the hearing, Joe Peznola, an expert on Chapter 40B developments hired by Edgartown officials as a consultant for the housing proposal, recommended the town continue its review.
Peznola pointed out that the MVC was ruled a “local board” by the Massachusetts Housing Appeals Committee in April following a lawsuit by Cumming after the denial of Edgartown Gardens. The ruling essentially stripped the commission of its ability to review Chapter 40B projects.
Peznola stated that the applicants, Cumming and his attorney Jay Talerman, “do not believe that the MVC has jurisdiction on Chapter 40Bs.”
“That matter is being adjudicated in the higher courts,” Peznola said. “But I think, in discussion with regards to possible different approaches than have been done in the past, because of some things that came out of Edgartown Gardens, we are recommending that the board continue the review of this Chapter 40B project … anticipating that the applicant may not go to MVC for a DRI.”
As the MVC is currently appealing the state ruling from April, Peznola said the ZBA should turn to peer-reviewed studies on aspects of Edgartown Cove, at least for now, instead of relying on an MVC review of the project. The ZBA agreed to ask the applicant (Cumming) to complete studies — on traffic, wastewater, and other potentially impactful aspects of the proposal — to present to the board at a later hearing, scheduled for Dec. 2. The studies are slated to cost around $17,000 and will be paid for by the applicants.
Less than a week after the hearing, on Monday, the Edgartown Select Board voted to send a letter to the zoning board of appeals. The select board acknowledged the zoning board’s authority but added that a “project of this scale has direct implications” for several other boards and departments under the purview of the select board. Members of the select board supported the use of working groups and “focused sessions” on wastewater, traffic, site design, and affordability, and asked to participate.
“In our view, this approach offers the best opportunity to resolve issues constructively with the applicant and to arrive at conditions that support the town,” the letter stated.
The Times spoke to James Hagerty, Edgartown town administrator, who reiterated that in his understanding, the town will continue their review of Edgartown Cove until a decision is made in the state legislature regarding the MVC’s authority over Chapter 40B projects. The letter, he said, is to ensure the select board has a voice in the town’s review process and the studies on traffic, wastewater, and other specifics outlined in the ZBA hearing.
Meanwhile, officials from the MVC maintain they have the ultimate authority over the project.
After the hearing, the executive director of the MVC, Adam Turner, told The Times, on the night of Oct. 28, that the town was required to refer Edgartown Cove under the MVC Act. The MVC Act is part of the legislation that formed the commission and includes many of its guiding principles. Under the act, a town cannot issue a permit for a referred project until the MVC reviews it.
“While the ZBA may decide to proceed with a parallel review under 40B simultaneous with the MVC’s DRI review, ultimately, under the MVC Act, the ZBA cannot issue a comprehensive permit for Edgartown Cove unless and until the MVC approves the project,” Turner told The Times over text.
Cumming told The Times on Oct. 28 that “the MVC can be a helpful advisor to the town, just as the Cape Cod Commission is to towns on the Cape. We look forward to receiving any MVC comments and working with the town to address them.”
Many specifics about the Edgartown Cove project, such as septic and traffic concerns, were broached at the ZBA meeting, and additional letters of opposition have appeared on the ZBA website this week. The floor was not opened to public comment on Oct. 28, but town officials said it will be at the next hearing in early December. ZBA members acknowledged that the Island community will likely be watching the proposal closely.
“We live on a very small island, and there’s a lot of interest in this particular application. And I just think keeping it as public and as transparent as possible is the smart move,” ZBA member Pamela Dolby said.
Editor’s note: Updated to include a letter submitted by the Edgartown Select Board to the Edgartown zoning board of appeals regarding Edgartown Cove on Nov. 2.


What angers me most is watching our housing crisis become an argument for weakening the scrutiny that protects this Island. Mr. Cumming says the MVC can be a “helpful advisor” while he challenges its authority to make binding decisions. To me, that is a remarkably convenient definition of cooperation. I support the ZBA’s unanimous decision to refer this project to the MVC. Wastewater, traffic, and environmental concerns deserve thorough examination and enforceable protections. This community will live with the consequences long after construction ends. Ten affordable homes matter. But their inclusion does not place thirty market-rate units, projected at $700,000 to $1.1 million each, above criticism. Our need for housing does not create an obligation to embrace every proposal carrying an affordable housing label. The jurisdictional dispute remains before the courts. Meanwhile, I expect public answers and rigorous review. Mr. Cumming, I will judge your commitment to this community by the protections you accept and the concerns you resolve. Welcoming comments is considerably less impressive when you are contesting the commenter’s authority. The Vineyard’s housing crisis should raise our expectations of developers. It should never require us to surrender them. Your profit margin is no measure of this Island’s wellbeing.