The Dukes County Jail on Main Street in Edgartown. —File photo by Michael Cummo

Dukes County Sheriff Robert (“Bob”) W. Ogden and 11 other Massachusetts sheriffs are asking state officials to amend what they say is a public safety gap in a new state law that limits local and state departments from cooperating with federal agents. 

The PROTECT Act, which took effect August 5, bars Massachusetts sheriffs and police from giving U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials advance notice before someone is released from jail. But in the case of individuals charged with serious or violent crimes who are subject to immigration detainers, there is worry among sheriffs about the safety of the public, especially when bail is set low . 

The new legislation was passed to prevent access to ICE and prohibit immigration arrests in schools, child care centers, health care facilities, nursing homes, and courthouses. It was also intended to restrict state and local police from using public facilities and resources to aid federal immigration enforcement and limits when law enforcement can ask about immigration status.

Signed into law by Gov. Maura Healey, parents can now pre-arrange guardianship for their children in case of ICE detainment or deportation; employers are required to tell employees if they receive an audit of their employment from ICE; and victims of certain crimes are eligible to more quickly secure a visa. According to the PROTECT Act, people can also sue government officials, including ICE agents, in state court for violating their constitutional rights.

“Governor Healey has worked closely with law enforcement and public safety officials, including sheriffs, throughout her career,” Jacqueline Manning, spokesperson for the governor, said in an email to The Times. “She will continue to work with them to address any public safety concerns. Governor Healey signed the PROTECT Act to keep ICE out of schools, daycares, hospitals and nursing homes and keep people safe.” 

Immigration enforcement remains a controversial issue on the Island. A raid by ICE in 2025 resulted in the detainment of around 20 individuals, and earlier this year, a father and son were taken into ICE custody while fishing off of Menemsha; neither had a criminal record.

But there have also been individuals from the Island taken by Enforcement and Removal Operations Boston, a branch of ICE that covers New England, with the types of charges that concern Ogden and other sheriffs. 

According to a letter sent to Healey’s office on Oct. 28 by the Massachusetts Sheriffs Association (MSA), the sheriffs are worried that the PROTECT Act prevents local law enforcement departments from notifying ICE agents when detainees, someone charged with a crime, are subject to immigration detainers and prior to their trial, post bail and are released. The sheriffs are especially concerned if those individuals face serious and violent charges, including, murder, assault, or drug trafficking. The only sheriffs in the state who didn’t sign the letter are Donna D. Buckley from Barnstable County and Peter J. Koutoujian from Middlesex County.

“I believe the ultimate goal of the MSA letter was to ensure that serious criminal matters are handled responsibly and that appropriate public-safety protections remain in place,” Ogden said in an email to The Times. 

The sheriffs are requesting that Healey’s office consider a legislative, regulatory, or administrative solution that permits limited, public safety-based notification when a pretrial detainee has a detainer on them and is charged with a “qualifying violent or dangerous offense.” 

According to the letter, the MSA also raised these concerns ahead of the PROTECT Act’s approval in August and noted that it could create a public safety risk. The letter stated that prohibiting notification to federal officials like ICE in advance means those federal agencies may need to locate that person in the community instead, which could create turmoil for the public and law enforcement, especially when families and others are present during an encounter.

“Another concern, which was realized on Martha’s Vineyard, is the potentially dangerous interaction between Federal agents and the general public while executing an ICE detainer,” Ogden said.

The letter stated that this isn’t a hypothetical concern, and that there were currently pretrial detainees in the custody of four of the sheriffs’ offices who are subject to immigration detainers, charged with a violent or dangerous offense, and have bail set below $1,000.

Ogden told The Times that after receiving the letter, Healey convened a meeting with her staff, the Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s office, and MSA leadership to discuss concerns on specific issues related to pretrial detainees.  

Ogden said that at the conclusion of the meeting, the governor requested three specific questions be answered by the sheriffs.

Here is the exchange for Dukes County, provided to The Times by Ogden: 

Gov. Healey’s office: For the categories of felonies for which advance notice may be given to ICE after completion of a sentence under the [PROTECT] Act* – Have there been people charged with any of those crimes, who are subject to an ICE detainer, and who you have had to release since the [PROTECT] Act took effect? If so, approximately how many? 

Dukes County Sheriff’s Office: Three pretrial releases this during calendar year 2026 with the following charges that meet the criteria if they had been sentenced:

6/9/26 Cocaine trafficking, $650 bail.

7/10/26 [in possession] to distribute class B [drug], $10,000 bail.

8/7/26 Kidnapping, Assault and Battery/Dangerous Weapon, $1500 bail.

Governor’s office: For the population of people in your custody who have ICE detainers, how many have prior convictions for any of the felonies listed in the [PROTECT] Act*?

DCSO: 0

Governor’s Office: More generally, how often do people make bail for the type of felonies listed in the [PROTECT] Act*?

DCSO: three to five per year. 

Ogden told The Times that the sheriffs haven’t heard back from the Governor’s office after providing the requested information, and no amendment has been drafted to the PROTECT Act. 

“As several of the examples cited in the MSA letter were related to detentions at the Dukes County Sheriff’s Office, right here on Martha’s Vineyard, particular consideration should be given to individuals held in county correctional facilities pending trial who are charged with serious felony or violent offenses and are also subject to outstanding federal immigration detainers,” Ogden said. 

Ogden wrote that while these individuals haven’t been convicted, “their criminal charges pose a significant risk to public safety.” The goal, the sheriff said, isn’t to “circumvent judicial release decisions or ignore statutory and constitutional authority,” but promote public safety. He underscored the “leniency” of bail imposed compared to the “gravity of the alleged crimes.” 

“These factors could inadvertently pose a threat to the public, when these individuals are released back into our community, without much ability to ensure their return to face the alleged crimes,” Ogden said.

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *