Tisbury Town Hall. —Eunki Seonwoo

Tisbury was forced to adjust proposed legislation to expand the select board membership after paperwork wasn’t submitted on time. 

The Tisbury Select Board unanimously approved amending the proposed petition on Wednesday, so that it would go into effect immediately if it’s passed by the state legislature rather than under a usual waiting period. 

“The reason we’re kind of in this jam of timeframe is because our application didn’t get in on time, so that’s kind of pushed everything back,” Connie Alexander, select board member, said at the meeting. She highlighted the board’s responsibility to uphold the will of the voters, who approved the board membership increase during the April town meeting. “Without it, we risk not doing what we were told to do. So, I’m just going to remind my fellow select board members that this is important tonight.” 

The proposal is to increase the select board from three to five members, started by town resident Lynne Fraker and Mary Bernadette Budinger-Cormie, a Tisbury planning board member and town representative on the Martha’s Vineyard Commission. The move was also seen by voters as a way to bring diversified expertise to the board, improve communication with the public, and prevent meeting cancellations because of a lack of quorum. Former select board chair Christina Colarusso resigned in December following legal trouble and months of absences from public meetings, so until a third member was elected in May (Alexander), the absence of a single board member would fail quorum.

Alexander told The Times that she was “perplexed” that the submission of the hard copy of the petition, which the state required, didn’t make the end of July deadline. She said the submission responsibility was with Joe LaCivita, the town administrator.

In a phone call with The Times, LaCivita, contested that the submission was late. He said an online submission was made on time and that the town had been communicating with State Sen. Julian Cyr and State Rep. Thomas Moakley. 

“We’re right on track,” he said. 

Alexander also said she received a call from Cyr’s office on Thursday, who was apparently happy about the amendment’s passage but plans to “circle back” if additional paperwork is not received in a timely fashion.

If the amended legislation passes at the state legislature, Tisbury voters would make their community the second town in Dukes County to have five members. Every Dukes County town has a three-member select board except Oak Bluffs, which currently has five members. The rest of the Cape and Islands have five-member select boards except for Barnstable, which has a town council with 13 seats. 

Devan Braun, town counsel from KP Law working on this issue, said the amendment eliminates a 30-day waiting period that usually accompanies home-rule petitions and the 10-days for the governor to sign it into law. Without this waiting period, the election process on-Island can begin quicker,  giving voters time for a special election to vote on the petition, and then, if approved, town residents can pull nomination papers for the annual town election in the spring. Alexander said she heard from the offices of Cyr and Moakley that the latest the state legislature can approve the amended petition is Jan. 5. The earliest a special town election can occur is Feb. 15. 

During the meeting, there was some confusion among town officials on the term lengths for the next election since the seat of board member Roy Cutrer will also be on the ballot. Cutrer and Budinger-Cormie said they understood it to be that each seat was for different terms (three years for Cutrer’s seat and two-year and one-year terms for the new offices) and that interested candidates would need to pull nomination papers for each office.

Braun said the current language in front of the state legislature states that two of the board seats would be for three-year terms and another for a two-year term. She said the candidates who get the highest number of votes get three-year terms, while the bronze medalist gets the two-year seat. 

“That’s how, at least the first election, is set to play out,” Braun said. “After that it would just take the normal process of ‘You run for the office that’s expiring, and you’re hoping to hold.’”

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *