A satellite image of the Cape and islands. —Wikimedia Commons

Months after the bill meant to establish a housing bank on Martha’s Vineyard quietly failed at the state legislature, housing advocates are calling for a united front with Nantucket to get this tool passed and subsequently fund housing initiatives on the Islands. 

Toward that end, the two islands’ separate land banks are seen by advocates as key pieces of the puzzle. Those details, however, are still being ironed out.

Members of the Coalition to Create the Martha’s Vineyard Housing Bank, a group of housing advocates, came before the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank commissioners on Monday to request a change in the agency’s affordable housing policy. The housing bank representatives proposed an amendment to the transfer fee structure of the land bank that would potentially add a funding stream for a housing bank if state lawmakers pass it.

John Abrams, a coalition steering committee member and founder emeritus of South Mountain Company, told the commissioners that a united front would be mutually beneficial. Not only would housing initiatives receive funds, but “it will protect the land bank from critics who believe enough land has been conserved and funds should only go to housing.” The land bank preserves 7 percent of the Island’s landmass for conservation, a portion of the 43 percent of conservation land overall.

“Conservation and community conservation are both sides of the same coin,” Abrams said. 

The housing bank is a proposed legislative measure to implement a one-time fee of 2 percent on real estate transactions of $1 million or more to be used for affordable housing initiatives, such as accessory dwelling units or the conversion of existing units.

While this is a measure that continues to receive Islanders’ support since it was approved by voters across the Vineyard during the 2022 town meetings, it received pushback from real estate lobbyists and eventually failed to pass muster in July in the state legislature. State Sen. Julian Cyr and State Rep. Thomas Moakley are preparing for a renewed push during the next legislative session in January, as are the local housing advocates. 

“Our commitment has not wavered. We are planning to continue this effort for as long as it takes to succeed,” Abrams said, highlighting that it took 20 years for the Community Preservation Act, which also took inspiration from the land bank transfer fee model that began on Nantucket in 1983, to get through state lawmakers. Abrams said he doesn’t believe the housing bank will take nearly as long.

Additionally, until now, the Vineyard and Nantucket introduced separate housing bank bills in an attempt to meet community needs, but Abrams said it was time to “band together with Nantucket.”

“We make a fence around the issue: two islands, two land banks, two housing transfer fees that might make the legislator and the real estate industry less wary and more willing to give it a go,” Abrams said, although he admitted it was uncertain what that would look like at this time. He floated some ideas, such as using home-rule petitions to introduce a local version of a housing bank or a “long-shot” ballot question, which would be enforceable statewide if passed. 

Talks are in the works with Nantucket officials and state legislators who represent the islands, but the coalition came to the Vineyard’s land bank, which has collaborated on various affordable housing projects before, first to test the waters. 

The Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank currently uses an existing 2 percent transfer fee on real estate transactions on the Island to fund conservation and land acquisitions. According to its affordable housing policy, any future increase to its transfer fee would allocate the additional amount to the Dukes County Regional Housing Authority for its “exclusive uses,” which the coalition hopes can instead be replaced to go to the housing bank. Prior to the legislature failing at the state level, the land bank already agreed to be the collection agency for the housing bank coalition. 

For the most part, commissioners were in favor of providing more support toward the effort during the meeting, but they wanted more details before changing policy. Sarah Thulin, Aquinnah commissioner, said she was “fearful” about potentially needing to go to state lawmakers. 

“I don’t necessarily trust there wouldn’t be refinement in our legislation, and I think sometimes the legislators are interested in clawing back … what they can,” Thulin said. 

Thulin was also worried about linking the Vineyard’s land bank so closely to the one on Nantucket, highlighting how they have different operational standards and goals. 

“I mean, they run a golf course,” she said. 

James Lengyel, land bank executive director, noted the proposed change wouldn’t need to go to Boston since it is “policy, not statute.” Additionally, he said only the islands’ land banks are designed as independent agencies with dedicated funding streams to be used “dynamically” whereas others, like Cape Cod, need funding approved at town meetings. 

“The reason that the two islands have the independent agencies is because the demand on the real estate was so intense that it was understood by everybody that they need to be able to act swiftly,” Lengyel said.

Steve Ewing, Edgartown commissioner, said the “boogieman, woman” of this effort is the real estate lobby, though he said it seemed the housing bank was met by resistance from off-Island realtors. Abrams said involving the islands’ real estate communities is a “big part of our strategy,” and they have been “tremendously supportive” of a housing bank so far. 

Ewing said the local realtors’ support made sense. 

“If you isolate the islands from the rest of the state with the proposal, what is the argument against it from the legislature?” he said. 

While no policy change was made Monday, Lengyel will be drafting a letter to the state for early December supporting the housing bank efforts.

Leave a comment

We are fortunate to have an engaged audience, so we receive many comments. We are not, however, able to publish all of them. That said, we do our best to lift the many different voices of our community. Read our comment policy here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *