New book gives a long, broad view of the Island landscape

David Foster in his West Tisbury home. — Bill Chaisson

David R. Foster’s “A Meeting of Land and Sea: Nature and the Future of Martha’s Vineyard” is a comprehensive look at the natural history of the Island, representing over 25 years of research. Mr. Foster is the director of Harvard Forest in Petersham, but maintains a seasonal home in West Tisbury. “My wife and I love this landscape,” he said in a recent interview with The Times. “It resonates with us more than any other.”

Mr. Foster has been at Harvard since 1983. The overarching goal of his research is to understand the processes that shape a landscape. Harvard Forest is one of 100 centers of long-term ecological research funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF). Its focus is on the whole of New England, but before 1990 its research was concentrated on inland ecosystems.

“In the early ‘90s we started to study the coast,” Mr. Foster said. “There are different environments, different human uses, and many rare and endangered species.” Between 1990 and 2005, the Mellon Foundation and NSF funded Harvard Forest staff to study the landscape history and ecology of Cape Cod and the Islands.

“A Meeting of Land and Sea” sprung from that research, but it is more than a translation of scientific papers. “I posed all the questions I was interested in,” Mr. Foster said. “Then I talked to a lot of people and included new material in every chapter.”

“The coastal ecosystem is unique,” Mr. Foster said, “and within that coastal ecosystem each place is unique.” Compared to other large islands in the Northeast, Martha’s Vineyard is diverse both as a natural system and as a culture. Cape Cod and Long Island, Mr. Foster said, are not as unique as Martha’s Vineyard because both of those land masses are more ecologically connected to the mainland.

As an electronic appendix to his book, Mr. Foster and his colleagues scanned a map of Martha’s Vineyard made by Henry Whiting in 1850 and scaled it to overlay a modern land-use map. It is available either for purchase or to inspect online (at A digital device called a swiper allows the viewer to inspect the changes in land use (or lack of them) between 1850 and 2016.

In “A Meeting of Land and Sea,” Mr. Foster reveals some of the manifold processes that produced the modern landscape. For example, Whiting’s map shows that the Island was covered by extensive stretches of unbroken woodland in the mid 19th century, when the rest of the New England landscape consisted largely of agricultural fields, pasture, and scattered woodlots. The vast sandy glacial outwash plain in the middle of the Island, now the site of the Manuel F. Correllus State Forest, was almost entirely woodland in 1850. According to Mr. Foster, the interior of the Island was too susceptible to drought to farm, so it was never cleared and settled.

Parts of the forest were cut over and burned, creating a mosaic of heathland and scrub oak. During the first three decades of the 20th century, about 600 acres of the plain served as a reserve for the endangered heath hen. After its extinction in 1932, the state purchased more of the plain and attempted to establish pine plantations, but the methods they used to plant trees didn’t change the forest’s makeup any more than cutting and burning had. The result, Mr. Foster said, is an extensive ancient woodland.

Oaks sprout from their roots after they are cut down or burned. Consequently, most of the trees that visitors see in the State Forest are coming up from root systems and trunks that are hundreds of years old. On Martha’s Vineyard, the interior forest was cut down in places, but it was never cleared for agriculture or grazing. The ancient soils and the plant community they support are still intact. The grasslands at the periphery of the Island, particularly along the south shore, are a legacy of agriculture and animal husbandry. “Nothing clears a forest like grazing animals,” Mr. Foster said.

One of the messages of “A Meeting of Land and Sea” is that land conservation should benefit the human population. He would like to see conservation lands play an economic role and not be viewed simply as a “place to play.”

“It seems to be just sitting there,” Mr. Foster said of some conserved land. Mr. Foster is on the board of The Trustees of Reservations, which owns Wasque. “Wasque could become part of the farm economy again. Instead of burning the fields at intervals, we should return to the traditional way of keeping the land open.”

The parts of Martha’s Vineyard that were open, Mr. Foster said, were kept that way by grazing animals. He says that open land is an important part of the ecosystem. “Don’t let it go back to forest,” he said. “Appreciate the diversity we have. Don’t use fire to keep it open, because fire didn’t generate it.”

“A Meeting of Land and Sea” is full of ideas like this. It is all presented in a large landscape format, illustrated with clear maps and photographs that are beautifully composed and help to tell the story. Sidebars and breakout boxes focus on technical topics or individual historical figures. Mr. Foster’s fluid prose winds through it all like a river among the boulders and trees.