Offshore Ale set to change hands

Offshore Ale will have new owners who plan to keep things the same. — Eunki Seonwoo

Offshore Ale Co. is set to get new owners, with a sale of the Kennebec Avenue staple and building to close next month.

Colleen and Phil McAndrews, who have owned the business since 2006, have an agreement to sell the restaurant to William and Susan Honeycutt of Medford for an undisclosed sum. The Honeycutts own John Brewers Tavern in Waltham and Malden. 

The popular brewpub is known for its signature beers and crushed peanut shells (pre-COVID) that carpet its floors.

Offshore Ale was first put on the market in 2017 for $4.2 million. At the time, Phil McAndrews said the decision came after the youngest of his and his wife’s children was set to leave for college in 2018. In 2018, however, the McAndrews decided to take the business off the market and continue running it. 

William Honeycutt said there are some plans to paint the building and renovate the windows, but otherwise it will be business as usual.

“Our intention is to continue the legacy that Phil and Colleen have built. We feel like the business is run well, the building is an asset to the town,” Honeycutt said.

The select board gave conditional approval for the liquor license transfer, with the condition that the McAndrews pay an outstanding parking mitigation fee to the town.

McAndrews said he had paid the bill annually, but fell behind in his payments when the town invoiced him $12,000 for back billing. He said the mitigation fee will be paid before the close of the sale.

Board members will take up the business’ entertainment license at a separate hearing on Oct. 26.

“We’re looking forward to doing business in Oak Bluffs, and we hope to be an asset to the community,” Honeycutt said.


  1. What other Business has a “Parking Mitigation Fee ” in Oak Bluffs?

    The Times should look into the topic.

  2. Thank you Colleen and Phil for the outstanding job you have done all these years, especially during COVID. I will miss you both and hope you continue to stop by. Long live Offshore!

  3. The comma in that “City, Ale & Oyster” sign bugs me every time I walk by. (Can’t help it: I’m an editor by trade!) Love the place — maybe the new owners will commission a new sign with Offshore’s real name on it?

    • OK Susanna- since it was my idea (and the original name of the brewery) I´ll address your point.
      The comma after City was a nod to the original name of the town, Cottage City, and was meant to separate it from Ále and Oyster´.
      I had thought that people would adopt the word City as a colloquial name for the place, as in ¨Let´s go grab a pint at The City´.
      Boy, was I ever wrong!

Comments are closed.