All those in favor


Our story about the controversial tower in Menemsha that’s been installed as part of a security camera system is a bit of a warning for town meeting voters.

The decision to pay for surveillance cameras in Menemsha was made at a Chilmark town meeting. The $20,000 paid by taxpayers and another $10,000 from the funds brought in through the harbor department were discussed at length, but it was more about the need for the cameras and the “Big Brother” element of them, and not about how they were going to be installed.

As one of our commenters wrote, the decision to install the tower was a “head-scratcher,” noting that the cement block is something “no one approved or knew about” before voting at that town meeting. 

Town meetings can move quickly, and sometimes feel a bit like inside baseball. With all the particular lingo, it can also be somewhat intimidating, and feel obscure and ambiguous.

With town meetings coming up next month in five of the Island towns — four of them on April 12, and one April 25 — and one in May, town leaders should do more to explain key items to voters. While those on town boards have had the luxury of discussing important items at meetings and with the finance committee, not all voters have the time to spend attending those meetings for background information. So it’s incumbent upon those who want town meeting voters to approve their expenditures to be patient and explain what it is they’re trying to accomplish, and why voters should support spending the money.

We also thought this would be a good time to provide a primer for those of you unfamiliar with key town meeting terms. So here goes.

Moderator: The person who presides over the meeting and declares the outcome of votes. The moderator also calls on people to present information and ask questions.

Annual town meeting: That’s a once-a-year town meeting where most of the town’s business is done, including setting the town budget.

Special town meeting: Often held multiple times a year, including at the same time as an annual town meeting, it’s often for things that didn’t meet the deadline to be considered at the annual town meeting, or can’t wait until the next annual town meeting. It can be confusing, but essentially it’s a safety net.

Quorum: The number of voters needed to consider the town’s business.

Warrant: That’s the document that contains all of the items to be voted on during a town meeting. They’re usually written in legalese, and you shouldn’t feel bad if you want town leaders to explain what they’re asking for in layman’s terms. The Oak Bluffs warrant is in this week’s issue in the classified section.

Articles: These are the individual items to be voted on, and are contained within the warrant. They’re numbered, and are read by the moderator. Sometimes they’re taken out of order, by a vote of town meeting.

Reconsideration: Voters on the winning side of an article can vote for reconsideration either if new information becomes available, or if they want to protect an item from being reconsidered and overturned later on, when some voters leave the town meeting. If the article is passed on reconsideration, it freezes the article as is.

Cherry sheet: This is a throwback to a time when the state would alert a town to the aid it was receiving on a red piece of paper. Now it’s done electronically, but you’ll still hear references to it.

Free cash: A misnomer, it’s actually taxpayer money that was approved at previous town meetings, but wasn’t spent for some reason. Perhaps the bids came in cheaper than the town anticipated for a project. The town can spend that money on other projects through a vote at town meeting.

Levy limit: That’s the amount of money the town can raise taxes to without asking for a Proposition 2½ override.

Override: There are several types. A general override is an amount to raise taxes over the levy limit, and is typically tied to a specific budget need of the town. It raises the levy limit permanently. A debt exclusion raises taxes for a specific purpose, perhaps a new school, and raises taxes for a period decided by town leaders. A new school might be for 20 or 30 years, for example. A capital exclusion raises taxes for one year, and is typically to purchase a piece of equipment like a fire engine or a snowplow. 

Fiscal year: It runs from July 1 to June 30. You’ll hear speakers refer to FY 23. 

Motion: There are many different types of motions, but what they have in common is that they propose some action by voters. Sometimes there are amendments to the “main motion,” which can get confusing. Don’t be afraid to ask for clarification on what you’re voting on.

Move the question: Reporters love when someone moves the question. It means the person has heard enough debate, and wants voters to take their vote. It’s not debatable, and requires a two-thirds majority to pass.

Point of order: When a voter at town meeting has a procedural question. Typically done after a speaker has finished. Moderators rule on points of order, typically with some legal guidance by town counsel.

Town meeting is the legislative body in a town, and only cities or towns with populations over 12,000 can have a town council or mayoral form of government. (Martha’s Vineyard could if it were one town.)

Town meetings are considered the purest form of democracy, and give every voter in town a voice. However, we should point out that taxpaying seasonal residents cannot vote at town meetings.

So as we enter town meeting season, we call on town leaders to slow down and be as transparent as possible. We’ll do our best to keep you informed on what’s coming up, but voters should feel free to ask questions, slow the process down, and make sure you understand that the security cameras you’re being asked to vote on may come at the expense of a tower that you find objectionable.

Make informed decisions.