What the bots are saying about Martha’s Vineyard’s seasonal economy


Below is an editorial generated by Chat GPT-4, an open-source, Artificial Intelligence “chatbot.” The editorial staff at The Times simply asked Chat GPT (by typing into a chat search bar): “Generate an editorial on staffing small businesses in a seasonal vacation destination like Martha’s Vineyard.” 

It took the chatbot about five seconds to generate the following, which was untouched by the editorial staff (despite our copy editor’s wishes). Chat GPT did not charge a fee. Further, the U.S. Copyright Office has found that AI systems are not protected under copyright law because the authors are not humans.


Nurturing Seasonal Small Businesses: The Staffing Challenge in Martha’s Vineyard



Martha’s Vineyard, with its breathtaking landscapes and idyllic charm, has long been a beloved vacation destination. However, beyond its allure as a seasonal paradise lies a significant challenge for small businesses that cater to the influx of visitors during peak seasons. Staffing these establishments adequately and efficiently is a daunting task. In this editorial, we delve into the unique staffing predicament faced by small businesses in a seasonal vacation destination like Martha’s Vineyard and explore potential solutions to help sustain their growth.


The Seasonal Staffing Conundrum:

Small businesses on Martha’s Vineyard often experience an extreme fluctuation in demand throughout the year. During the bustling summer months, the island’s population can increase exponentially, placing immense strain on local establishments to meet the needs of both residents and visitors. However, as a autumn approaches and winter sets in, the once-thriving businesses struggle to retain their workforce due to decreased footfall and revenue. This seasonal staffing conundrum poses significant challenges for businesses, jeopardizing their ability to provide consistent service quality and hinder their long-term sustainability.


Challenges Faced by Small Businesses:

Limited Local Workforce: Martha’s Vineyard is a small island with a relatively small year-round population. The limited local workforce presents challenges when attempting to fill numerous positions during the peak season.

Shortage of Affordable Housing: Accommodation scarcity is a long-standing issue on the island. This shortage often discourages potential employees from seeking employment, particularly if they cannot secure affordable and suitable housing.

High Cost of Living: The high cost of living on Martha’s Vineyard can make it difficult for businesses to attract and retain staff, especially when competing with mainland establishments offering higher wages.

Seasonal Labor Market: The transient nature of seasonal employment makes it challenging for businesses to find reliable and experienced staff each year. This turnover adds significant overhead costs associated with training new employees.

Potential Solutions:

Collaborative Initiatives: Local businesses could collaborate to create a shared pool of seasonal staff. By working together, they can share resources, conduct joint recruitment efforts, and offer incentives to attract potential employees. This approach would help businesses overcome the burden of staffing on an individual level while fostering a sense of community support.

Employee Housing Programs: Establishing partnerships between small businesses and local government to develop affordable employee housing programs can alleviate the housing crunch. Offering subsidized housing or shared accommodations could make seasonal employment more attractive and accessible for workers.

Enhanced Compensation Packages: Small businesses can consider offering competitive compensation packages that go beyond just wages. Additional benefits like flexible schedules, employee discounts, career development opportunities, and performance-based incentives can entice employees to commit to seasonal positions.

Cultivating Local Talent: Investing in training and development programs that cater to local residents can help nurture a pool of skilled workers who can fill seasonal positions. By empowering the local community, businesses can reduce reliance on transient labor and build a loyal and reliable workforce.



The staffing challenges faced by small businesses in seasonal vacation destinations like Martha’s Vineyard require innovative solutions and collaborative efforts. By addressing the unique dynamics of the island’s labor market, such as limited workforce, housing scarcity, and seasonal fluctuations, businesses can improve their ability to attract and retain employees. Local businesses, government authorities, and community organizations must join hands to create sustainable solutions that preserve the essence and vitality of Martha’s Vineyard while ensuring the success of its small businesses. By nurturing a stable and dedicated workforce, the island can continue to enchant visitors and residents alike with its warm hospitality and exceptional service year after year.


  1. Obviously not human! “Local businesses, government authorities, and community organizations must join hands to create sustainable solutions”, if only!!

    Also, it has “as a autumn”, it should know better. It is “as AN autumn”, so how smart is that Chat GP-4?

    All the points are correct in aggregate.

Comments are closed.