There is a specific kind of happiness that only reveals itself when you are sitting on a sun-warmed beach blanket on Norton Point (if you’re lucky and the piping plovers will let you) with sand between your toes, a cold drink sweating in your hand, and something truly delicious in the other. No tablecloth, no reservation, no shoes required. On Martha’s Vineyard in July, eating outside is not simply a dining preference or a casual afterthought. It is a ritual, a philosophy, and honestly, one of the best arguments for why this Island draws people back summer after summer without fail.
The Art of the Beach Picnic
A great beach picnic does not happen by accident, and any islander will tell you that the best outdoor meals are the result of shopping (whether it’s thoughtful and calm at Morning Glory Farm or frantic and chaotic at Stop & Shop) and an honest understanding of what actually tastes good once it has been sitting in a tote bag for forty-five minutes in the July heat. The foundation is always the same: something cold, something salty, something sweet, and enough drinks (boozy or not) to keep you entertained.
What you actually want when you are sitting at South Beach or Lambert’s Cove are foods that travel well and reward you at room temperature just as generously as they do straight from the refrigerator. A good, sturdy loaf of Maison Villate bread that you picked up at North Tisbury Farm, a wedge of Mermaid Farm Gouda cheese, fruit that is at the peak of its season like those overpriced but oh so worth it Goldbud peaches. Add in a snack from the sea, like the tuna salad from John’s Fish Market, because you are on an island and there is simply no excuse not to.
You can’t forget the snacks: olives, nuts, a good cracker situation. Then there is the main event, something wrapped or assembled and designed to be eaten without utensils while a seagull eyes you from twelve feet away. Rumor has it my husband had a seagull once steal an entire bagel with veggie cream cheese from his hand on South Beach, so you’ve been warned. And if you’re like me, you’ve put the same amount of thought into the sweet as you have the savory. Might I suggest a couple brownies from Morning Glory Farm or if it’s Saturday, a few fresh donuts made by Korilee at Mo’s Lunch?
Local tip: “The best outdoor picnic combines a perfect balance of seclusion and good company. For me, the perfect spot is at East Beach on Chappy. I drive out with my grill in the back of my truck, the best of friends in the cab, and enough hotdogs and accoutrements to last us all day. A perfect day comes to an end as the sun dips low, and I finish cooking a few last dogs for the drive to the ferry and back home.” – Chris Look, Circulation Assistant, Edgartown Public Library
Where to Stock Up: The Island’s Best Picnic Provisions
Building the right outdoor spread on Island is one of summer’s great pleasures, largely because the sourcing itself is part of the experience. As always, I’ll suggest shopping your fridge and pantry first – those scraps of cheese wedges in your drawer, a few half-eaten boxes of crackers, the random chocolate bars in the baking cabinet – starting with what you have is always the best idea! But then, you can hit the local spots: Morning Glory Farm remains the undisputed anchor of any serious July picnic, its stand overflowing with heirloom tomatoes, stone fruit, fresh herbs, and jams that taste like someone put the entire season into a jar. Pick up their farmstand sourdough bread, grab whatever fruit looks best that morning, and consider a wedge of something from their prepared foods section that will be exactly right by the time you reach your blanket.
For protein, a local fish market changes everything, and the Vineyard’s access to day-boat seafood is one of the Island’s most underappreciated advantages. Most local markets carry MV Smokehouse’s signature smoked bluefish spread or their smoked spicy yellowfin tuna spread – two of my favorite spreads and I can personally consume one of those containers on my own, no sharing. They are two of those Island staples that visitors discover once and spend the rest of the year trying to replicate at home, always unsuccessfully, because the secret is the fish itself and where it came from. Lobster rolls, fresh oysters, steamers – all make up a banquet of delicious eats for your picnics!
Edgartown Seafood is another essential stop, particularly for those who want their seafood prepared and ready to eat. Their smoked and prepared fish options travel beautifully and pair perfectly with good bread and a cold bottle of whatever you’re drinking, packed wisely in your cooler. Just be smart about any seafood products you bring to the beach – those need to be the first items consumed, for obvious food safety reasons!
Local tip: “Depending on the vibe, my go-to spots are pretty well mapped out at this point. For a full family beach day at State Beach, I go the DIY route and stock up on everything at Reliable Market. If I’m craving the best turkey club around while posted up at the Inkwell, Tigerhawk is the answer every time. And if there’s a bottle of rosé and my girlfriends involved, it’s Black Sheep all day for delicious bites from a beach chair at a quiet spot, or we take it to Menemsha and pair it with a lobster.” – Kharma Finley-Wallace, HoverFly Events
Grab and Go Done Right
The Island’s grab-and-go culture has matured considerably in recent years. Across the Island you will find sandwich shops, bakeries, and coffee shops preparing grab and go options that will make your beach picnic life much easier, here are just a few:
- Quitsa Kitchen, Vineyard Haven
- Catboat Coffee Co., Vineyard Haven
- Highlands General, Oak Bluffs
- Tony’s Market, Oak Bluffs
- Morning Glory Farm, Edgartown
- Great Harbor Market, Edgartown
- Chilmark General Store, Chilmark
- Beetlebung Farm Stand, Chilmak
- Aquila Cafe, Aquinnah
- Orange Peel Bakery, Aquinnah
Local Tip: “Depending on which direction I am headed to the beach, I love Katama General’s grab & go sandwiches and provisions. Their tuna salad with a bag of truffle chips can’t be beat. Match that with some delicious seltzer waters or their rose and spiked seltzer options. Headed up island, I always stop by Black Sheep. They have a wealth of options like their tortellini salad and salads to take to the beach with yummy drink options. Their cracklebread is a MUST. I also love their 9th Hole Mix for snacking. Oak Bluffs is either Nomans or Highlands General. They have great beach provisions and fun snacks. I recently discovered their Mermaid Mix gummies and wish I hadn’t!” – Leah Fraumeni, local concierge
Outdoor Dining: When a Table and a View Are All You Need
The Island’s outdoor dining scene has grown into something genuinely worth celebrating, with restaurants investing in their outdoor spaces in ways that make sense rather than simply adding a few chairs to a space.
Eating outside in July on the Vineyard means eating with the Island itself as your backdrop – the setting does not just complement the food. In many ways, it completes it. Here’s where you should be spending some time, al fresco:
- El Barco, Vineyard Haven
- Maker Cafe, Vineyard Haven
- The Wave Restaurant & Bar, Vineyard Haven
- The Dunes at the Winnetu Oceanside Resort, Edgartown
- 19 Raw Oyster Bar & Steakhouse, Edgartown
- Atria, Edgartown
- Nomans, Oak Bluffs
- Sandbar Grille, Oak Bluffs
- Offshore Ale Co., Oak Bluffs
- Menemsha Galley, Menemsha
Local Tip: “Outdoor dining in the summer is basically a non-negotiable when you have two boys. They need space to move, to get up from the table seventeen times without anyone giving you a look. When we eat outside, everyone is happier, including me. The Island makes it so easy because you are never far from a picnic table, a patch of grass, or a beach where you can spread out a blanket and just let them be kids. Summer eating outside is not just a preference for our family. It is a survival strategy.” – Megan Shai Brown, mom to Miles and Calvin
What Makes It All Work
A great outdoor meal on the Vineyard is less a product of perfection than of genuine intention, and I will tell you that the best picnics are really just good shopping plus a little forethought:
- Bring more blankets than you think you need – one is never enough.
- Pack a proper insulated cooler and do not skimp on the ice.
- Bring napkins, but wet wipes are an even better idea.
- Find a spot with a view or a breeze, ideally both.
The Island in July is extraordinarily generous with its gifts: the light is long and golden well into the evening, the produce is at the peak of everything it is capable of being, and the fish is as close to the ocean as it will ever get before it reaches your plate. Every outdoor meal here, whether it is a thoughtfully assembled picnic at State Beach or chips and tuna salad eaten standing next to your car on Norton Point, feels like someone designed the whole afternoon with intention.
That is the Martha’s Vineyard July table. Pull up a blanket and eat it while you can.
This article is published as a part of The Grapevine–a monthly email newsletter dedicated to our local events and culinary scene. Click here to subscribe to the newsletter.